Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Blogs | Writers | Paid | My Orble | Login

More





A Brownlow update




Could I be so bold as to suggest that there are realistically only three runners in the race for the Brownlow Medal?

The unofficial guidelines for the Brownlow are as follows:
1) The player is a well-known midfielder; and,
2) The player's club finishes in the top four for the home and away season.


Only twice have these guidelines been broken: once by Chris Judd in 2004 when his Eagles finished in eighth place; and once in 2003 when Mark Ricciuto’s Crows finished fifth for the season.

In 2010 there are three genuine contenders: Luke Hodge, Dane Swan, and Lenny Hayes.

What are the chances?

Luke Hodge:

Hawthorn currently sits in eighth place on the ladder, with no mathematical chance of them slipping into the top four by round twenty-two. They've won ten of their twenty games, with the potential to secure eleven by season's end. Therefore, in theory, it is assumed that Hodge has only the chance of securing substantive Brownlow votes in eleven of the twenty-two games. Last year, the Cats won eighteen of their twenty two games and Gary Ablett tallied thirty votes to win the brownlow. This poses quite a challenge for Hodge, who would nearly have to poll all three votes in every game that the Hawks have won.

Brownlow rating: 5/10

Dane Swan:

Last year Dane Swan had a breakthrough year, proving his magnetism for the ball around close contest. He was named the Herald Sun Player of the Year, All-Australian, and runner up for the MVP award. But this was not enough to secure him Brownlow Votes, so much so that he fell outside the top ten place getters.


This year, the Magpies have helped Swan's chances by no doubt finishing first on the ladder, with potentially eighteen wins. However, one must ask whether the tattoos that stain his upper body are a blemish that hinder any potential best and fairest recognition.

Brownlow rating: 7/10

Lenny Hayes

Lenny Hayes has proven himself the heartbeat of the St Kilda midfield. In the absence of Nick Riewoldt for much of the season, Hayes has proven himself the standout man to take his Saints into the grand final hunt for the second time in two years. Hard at the contest and a generous ball user, Hayes finished third in the 2009 count, below Ablett and Judd.

Although St Kilda's 2010 campaign unmatched the one launched in '09, they've still managed fourteen wins to date and an assured top four placing. In my mind, Hayes has a neck out lead over Swan and a broad stroke over Hodge.

Brownlow rating: 8/10

Add CommentsAdd Comments
32
Vote
   


Finals Edition



With two weeks until the finals get underway there seems to be only three teams in the competition that can confidently offer their hand for the flag: Collingwood, Geelong, and St Kilda.

While the Magpies have shown they're the best home and away side of 2010, their infamous finals’ history does little to convince me of their prospective dominance this time around.

The Cats have lacked something in '10, but there is a weighty expectation they will take the finals in their normal bustling stride.

The Saints are a mixed bag. Without Riewoldt they became unstoppable. With Riewoldt's return, they've taken time to adjust, with some structure issues in the beginning, but have since found a fragment of their 2009 form.

AFL Insider has been out of commission for a large portion of the second half of the season. Now, with the finals on the not-to-distant horizon, we are back to provide an informed and up to date coverage.

Over the next few weeks we will unpack the year that was 2010, discuss the Brownlow, and prepare for that day in September.

If your team has made the cut, good luck! If not, enjoy the next six weeks of footy in stress-free luxury.


Add CommentsAdd Comments
49
Vote
   


Wednesday Question: Brendan Fevola

The much anticipated clash between Carlton and the Brisbane Lions has lost its heat after Brendan Fevola was moved to the injury list late this week. The question: is he really injured, or is coach Michael Voss merely taking a back door opportunity to ground the form slumping star?

Add CommentsAdd Comments
104
Vote
   


Tuesday Predictions



Short Term Predictions

Riewoldt will return this weekend!

Hawthorn’s winning streak will come to an end

Long Term Predictions

West Coast to finish wooden spooners

Geelong’s window of success will close at the end of 2010

----------------------------- -----------------------------

Brownlow Medal: Luke Hodge

Coleman Medal:
Jack Riewoldt

Top Four: 1. Geelong 2. St Kilda 3. Collingwood 4. Fremantle

Premiership Teams:
Geelong v Collingwood

Premiership Winner:
Geelong

Norm Smith Medal: Gary Ablett Jnr

Rising Star:
Jack Trentgrove

All Australian Captain: Matthew Pavlich
Add CommentsAdd Comments
109
Vote
   


The Wednesday Question: the wooden spoon

John Worsfold went publicly recently, with the bold statement that his West Coast Eagles would not win the wooden spoon in 2010. In my mind, there are five teams in the hunt for the spoon: Richmond, Adelaide, West Coast, Melbourne, Port Adelaide. Who will win the accolade, and why?

Add CommentsAdd Comments
112
Vote
   


The return of St Nick!

Warning:

To the other fifteen teams in the AFL competition. This article contains content that may shock and shake you; it may tremble the tips of your top four grasping fingers; it may lead to acts of desperation and severe inner reflection. If you are currently experiencing the symptoms of finals confidence— excitement, jitters, joy, smile headaches— then avoid this prescription at all costs. Those of you who take no notice of this warning, or ignore its potent message, beware…

For Nick Riewoldt is returning!


He left the literal and figurative park in the round three clash between Collingwood and the Saints. He suffered a severe, three month debilitating, hamstring injury. He has backed into the darkness of recovery and rehab and we’ve heard little from him since. In the next few weeks, he will emerge from the unknown darkness and fall back into the sharp spotlight.

http://www.abc.net.au/reslib/201004/r546218_3204113.jpg


At the end of last season and the start of this one, Riewoldt was doted as the most indispensable player in the league. Captain of St Kilda, he is a murderous force at centre half forward and demands perfection from his own game and the games of the seventeen other men that structure around him.

He was an integral feature of St Kilda’s 2009 campaign, in which his Saints finished runner up to the legendary Geelong Cats. Most predict that without St Nick at the helm, the Saints have no chance of repeating or bettering their 2009 feat.

However, until now, they’ve managed quite impressively in his absence. With the genius of Stevie Milne, and the hardened presence of Lenny Hayes as stand-in captain, St Kilda has kept its top four position.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/common/imagedata/0,5001,6640394,00.jpg


The question, quite unpredictably, has become whether coach Ross Lyon can reintroduce his endangered species back into the wild… without the entire ecosystem falling down around him.

To do it successfully, he will need to maintain his strong support for those who have stepped up in Riewoldt’s absence, to ensure the load does not merely burden itself back onto the skipper’s weary shoulders. Hayes, Milne, Goddard, Montagne. These are the names that need to be heard collectively above the often deafening praise for their broad shouldered leader.

If Nick needs any more incentive to return to the literal footy park, it will come with the revelation of his cousin, Jack. This younger cousin Riewoldt has kicked 26 goals in his last four outings and leads the Coleman Medal quite convincingly. For Nick to have any standing at the family Christmas barbecue this year he needs to return to what he did best…

… Dominating!

http://www.zimbio.com/pictures/bUPZWPSX2p0/St Kilda Training Session/LS08niYXGK4/Nick Riewoldt



Add CommentsAdd Comments
91
Vote
   


Round 12, Week 1


(Game of the round: Carlton v Fremantle)

Round Twelve: Friday Night—Hawthorn v Essendon

Venue: MCG (Hawthorn Home)

Ladder Positions: Hawthorn (8th); Essendon (10th)

Last three games: Hawthorn (win/win/win); Essendon (lose/lose/win)

Favourite: Hawthorn

My Tip: Essendon by 10 points

Why?: Hawthorn aren’t Geelong!

Best on ground: Alwyn Davey




Round Twelve: Saturday Afternoon—Carlton v Fremantle

Venue: Etihad Stadium (Carlton Home)

Ladder Positions: Carlton (6th); Fremantle (4th)

Last three games: Carlton (lose/win/win); Fremantle (lose/lose/win)

Favourite: Carlton

My Tip: Fremantle by 33

Why?: Return of the Pav!

Best on ground: Matthew Pavlich




Round Twelve: Saturday Night—Brisbane v Richmond

Venue: Gabba (Brisbane Home)

Ladder Positions: Brisbane (11th); Richmond (16th)

Last three games: Brisbane (lose/lose/win); Richmond (win/lose/win)

Favourite: Brisbane

My Tip: Brisbane by 24

Why?: Home ground advantage!

Best on ground: Daniel Rich




Round Twelve: Sunday Afternoon— North Melbourne v Port Adelaide

Venue: Etihad Stadium (North Melbourne Home)

Ladder Positions: North Melbourne (9th); Port Adelaide (12th)

Last three games: North Melbourne (win/win/lose); Port Adelaide (lose/lose/lose)

Favourite: North Melbourne

My Tip: Port Adelaide by 15

Why?: Pride!

Best on ground: Dean Brogan




Round Twelve: Sunday Afternoon—West Coast v Western Bulldogs

Venue: Subiaco (West Coast Home)

Ladder Positions: Western Bulldogs (5th); West Coast (14th)

Last three games: Western Bulldogs (win/lose/lose); West Coast (lose/lose/lose)

Favourite: Western Bulldogs

My Tip: Western Bulldogs by 40

Why?: Top four!

Best on ground: Adam Cooney
Comments (1)Comments (1) Add CommentsAdd Comments
147
Vote
   


The Wednesday Question: Drawn Games

Monday's Queen's Day Birthday clash saw Melbourne and Collingwood record the first draw for the season. It sparked the perennial question: should draws remain a reality in the home and away season, and the finals series; or, should the AFL install a time-on policy where play continues for another 5-10 minutes?

Add CommentsAdd Comments
110
Vote
   


Tuesday Predictions




Short Term Predictions

St Kilda to upset Geelong

Jack Riewoldt to kick 4 against the lions

Long Term Predictions

Fremantle to end season out of top four

Karmichael Hunt to leave AFL after contract expires

----------------------------- -----------------------------

Brownlow Medal: Luke Hodge

Coleman Medal:
Barry Hall

Top Four: 1. Geelong 2. St Kilda 3. Collingwood 4. Bulldogs

Premiership Teams: Geelong v Collingwood

Premiership Winner:
Geelong

Norm Smith Medal: Joel Selwood

Rising Star: Nathan Fyfe

All Australian Captain: Matthew Pavlich
Add CommentsAdd Comments
112
Vote
   


Round 11 Previews



(Game of the round: Fremantle v St Kilda)




Round Eleven: Friday Night—North Melbourne v Carlton

Venue: Etihad Stadium (North Melbourne Home)

Ladder Positions: Carlton (5th); North Melbourne (12th)

Last three games: Carlton (win/win/lose); North Melbourne (win/lose/lose)

Favourite: Carlton

My Tip: Carlton by 30 points

Why?: Good form!

Best on ground: Chris Judd




Round Eleven: Saturday Afternoon—Hawthorn v Adelaide

Venue: Aurora (Hawthorn Home)

Ladder Positions: Hawthorn (8th); Adelaide (15th)

Last three games: Hawthorn (win/win/win); Adelaide (win/lose/win)

Favourite: Hawthorn

My Tip: Hawthorn by 33

Why?: Buddy’s Back!

Best on ground: Lance Franklin




Round Eleven: Saturday Night—Essendon v Geelong

Venue: Etihad Stadium (Essendon Home)

Ladder Positions: Geelong (1st); Essendon (9th)

Last three games: Geelong (win/win/win); Essendon (lose/win/win)

Favourite: Geelong

My Tip: Geelong by 45

Why?: Too good!

Best on ground: Jimmy Bartel




Round Eleven: Saturday Night—Port Adelaide v Sydney

Venue: AAMI Stadium (Port Adelaide Home)

Ladder Positions: Port Adelaide (11th); Sydney (7th)

Last three games: Port Adelaide (lose/lose/lose); Sydney (win/lose/lose)

Favourite: Port Adelaide

My Tip: Sydney by 7

Why?: Better team!

Best on ground: Brett Kirk




Round Eleven: Sunday Afternoon—Richmond v West Coast

Venue: MCG (Richmond Home)

Ladder Positions: Richmond (16th); West Coast (14th)

Last three games: Richmond (lose/win/lose); West Coast (lose/lose/lose)

Favourite: Richmond

My Tip: West Coast by 14

Why?: For the coach!

Best on ground: Mark LeCras




Round Eleven: Sunday Afternoon—Western Bulldogs v Brisbane

Venue: Etihad Stadium (Western Bulldogs Home)

Ladder Positions: Western Bulldogs (6th); Brisbane (10th)

Last three games: Western Bulldogs (lose/lose/win); Brisbane (lose/win/lose)

Favourite: Western Bulldogs

My Tip: Western Bulldogs by 35

Why?: Top four hunger!

Best on ground: Adam Cooney




Round Eleven: Sunday Afternoon—Fremantle v St Kilda

Venue: Subiaco (Fremantle Home)

Ladder Positions: St Kilda (3rd); Fremantle (4th)

Last three games: St Kilda (win/win/win); Fremantle (lose/win/win)

Favourite: Fremantle

My Tip: St Kilda by 15

Why?: Mid season chokers!

Best on ground: Lenny Hayes



Round Eleven: Monday Afternoon—Melbourne v Collingwood

Venue: MCG (Melbourne Home)

Ladder Positions: Melbourne (13th); Collingwood (2nd)

Last three games: Melbourne (lose/lose/win); Collingwood (win/lose/lose)

Favourite: Collingwood

My Tip: Collingwood by 40

Why?: Premiership hunger!

Best on ground: Alan Didak




Add CommentsAdd Comments
90
Vote
   


More Posts
2 Posts
23 Posts
21 Posts
2161 Posts dating from January 2006
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:

Tom Slack 2's Blogs

I have no other blogs :(
Moderated by Tom Slack 2
Copyright © 2006 2007 2008 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]