Could I be so bold as to suggest that there are realistically only three runners in the race for the Brownlow Medal?
The unofficial guidelines for the Brownlow are as follows:
1) The player is a well-known midfielder; and,
2) The player's club finishes in the top four for the home and away season.
Only twice have these guidelines been broken: once by Chris Judd in 2004 when his Eagles finished in eighth place; and once in 2003 when Mark Ricciuto’s Crows finished fifth for the season.
In 2010 there are three genuine contenders: Luke Hodge, Dane Swan, and Lenny Hayes.
What are the chances?
Luke Hodge:
Hawthorn currently sits in eighth place on the ladder, with no mathematical chance of them slipping into the top four by round twenty-two. They've won ten of their twenty games, with the potential to secure eleven by season's end. Therefore, in theory, it is assumed that Hodge has only the chance of securing substantive Brownlow votes in eleven of the twenty-two games. Last year, the Cats won eighteen of their twenty two games and Gary Ablett tallied thirty votes to win the brownlow. This poses quite a challenge for Hodge, who would nearly have to poll all three votes in every game that the Hawks have won.
Brownlow rating: 5/10
Dane Swan:
Last year Dane Swan had a breakthrough year, proving his magnetism for the ball around close contest. He was named the Herald Sun Player of the Year, All-Australian, and runner up for the MVP award. But this was not enough to secure him Brownlow Votes, so much so that he fell outside the top ten place getters.
This year, the Magpies have helped Swan's chances by no doubt finishing first on the ladder, with potentially eighteen wins. However, one must ask whether the tattoos that stain his upper body are a blemish that hinder any potential best and fairest recognition.
Brownlow rating: 7/10
Lenny Hayes
Lenny Hayes has proven himself the heartbeat of the St Kilda midfield. In the absence of Nick Riewoldt for much of the season, Hayes has proven himself the standout man to take his Saints into the grand final hunt for the second time in two years. Hard at the contest and a generous ball user, Hayes finished third in the 2009 count, below Ablett and Judd.
Although St Kilda's 2010 campaign unmatched the one launched in '09, they've still managed fourteen wins to date and an assured top four placing. In my mind, Hayes has a neck out lead over Swan and a broad stroke over Hodge.
With two weeks until the finals get underway there seems to be only three teams in the competition that can confidently offer their hand for the flag: Collingwood, Geelong, and St Kilda.
While the Magpies have shown they're the best home and away side of 2010, their infamous finals’ history does little to convince me of their prospective dominance this time around.
The Cats have lacked something in '10, but there is a weighty expectation they will take the finals in their normal bustling stride.
The Saints are a mixed bag. Without Riewoldt they became unstoppable. With Riewoldt's return, they've taken time to adjust, with some structure issues in the beginning, but have since found a fragment of their 2009 form.
AFL Insider has been out of commission for a large portion of the second half of the season. Now, with the finals on the not-to-distant horizon, we are back to provide an informed and up to date coverage.
Over the next few weeks we will unpack the year that was 2010, discuss the Brownlow, and prepare for that day in September.
If your team has made the cut, good luck! If not, enjoy the next six weeks of footy in stress-free luxury.
The much anticipated clash between Carlton and the Brisbane Lions has lost its heat after Brendan Fevola was moved to the injury list late this week. The question: is he really injured, or is coach Michael Voss merely taking a back door opportunity to ground the form slumping star?
John Worsfold went publicly recently, with the bold statement that his West Coast Eagles would not win the wooden spoon in 2010. In my mind, there are five teams in the hunt for the spoon: Richmond, Adelaide, West Coast, Melbourne, Port Adelaide. Who will win the accolade, and why?
To the other fifteen teams in the AFL competition. This article contains content that may shock and shake you; it may tremble the tips of your top four grasping fingers; it may lead to acts of desperation and severe inner reflection. If you are currently experiencing the symptoms of finals confidence— excitement, jitters, joy, smile headaches— then avoid this prescription at all costs. Those of you who take no notice of this warning, or ignore its potent message, beware…
For Nick Riewoldt is returning!
He left the literal and figurative park in the round three clash between Collingwood and the Saints. He suffered a severe, three month debilitating, hamstring injury. He has backed into the darkness of recovery and rehab and we’ve heard little from him since. In the next few weeks, he will emerge from the unknown darkness and fall back into the sharp spotlight.
At the end of last season and the start of this one, Riewoldt was doted as the most indispensable player in the league. Captain of St Kilda, he is a murderous force at centre half forward and demands perfection from his own game and the games of the seventeen other men that structure around him.
He was an integral feature of St Kilda’s 2009 campaign, in which his Saints finished runner up to the legendary Geelong Cats. Most predict that without St Nick at the helm, the Saints have no chance of repeating or bettering their 2009 feat.
However, until now, they’ve managed quite impressively in his absence. With the genius of Stevie Milne, and the hardened presence of Lenny Hayes as stand-in captain, St Kilda has kept its top four position.
The question, quite unpredictably, has become whether coach Ross Lyon can reintroduce his endangered species back into the wild… without the entire ecosystem falling down around him.
To do it successfully, he will need to maintain his strong support for those who have stepped up in Riewoldt’s absence, to ensure the load does not merely burden itself back onto the skipper’s weary shoulders. Hayes, Milne, Goddard, Montagne. These are the names that need to be heard collectively above the often deafening praise for their broad shouldered leader.
If Nick needs any more incentive to return to the literal footy park, it will come with the revelation of his cousin, Jack. This younger cousin Riewoldt has kicked 26 goals in his last four outings and leads the Coleman Medal quite convincingly. For Nick to have any standing at the family Christmas barbecue this year he needs to return to what he did best…
… Dominating!
http://www.zimbio.com/pictures/bUPZWPSX2p0/St Kilda Training Session/LS08niYXGK4/Nick Riewoldt
Monday's Queen's Day Birthday clash saw Melbourne and Collingwood record the first draw for the season. It sparked the perennial question: should draws remain a reality in the home and away season, and the finals series; or, should the AFL install a time-on policy where play continues for another 5-10 minutes?
In 2011 and 2012, the new Gold Coast and Greater Western Sydney Football Clubs will enter the AFL competition and we will hopefully start to see the fruits of the millions of dollars invested in Israel Folau and Karmichael Hunt. Will we be satisfied with our investment? Which, if either, will meet and exceed our expectations? Which, if either, will fall dangerously short of them?
Richmond to get second win of the season against West Coast
Saints to take down Fremantle at Subiaco
Long Term Predictions
Lions to fall further after injuries and drop to bottom six team by end of 2010
Tigers to struggle for next two years with inception of two new teams into competition
----------------------------- -----------------------------
Brownlow Medal: Lenny Hayes
Coleman Medal: Matthew Pavlich
Top Four: 1. Geelong 2. Collingwood 3. St Kilda 4. Fremantle
2011 is going to be a tough year for whichever team finishes in the bottom four places on the ladder.
As part of the inception of the new Gold Coast team, next year’s draft arrangement has been significantly modified to give the new club enough chances to hit the ground running.
The AFL draft system is divided into three rounds. Ordinarily, it works in a reverse order to the previous years premiership ladder, designating the first pick to the team that finished 16th, and so on. However, this year and next, it will work differently to include firstly the Gold Coast team, and eventually the GWS club. The following illustrates how it will be implemented at the end of this year:
Round one
1 Gold Coast
2 Gold Coast
3 Gold Coast
4 Club 16 on 2010 ladder
5 Gold Coast
6 Club 15 on 2010 ladder
7 Gold Coast
8 Club 14 on 2010 ladder
9 Gold Coast
10 Club 13 on 2010 ladder
11 Gold Coast
12 Club 12 on 2010 ladder
13 Gold Coast
14 Club 11 on 2010 ladder
15 Gold Coast
16 Club 10 on 2010 ladder
17 Club 9 on 2010 ladder
18 Club 8 on 2010 ladder
19 Club 7 on 2010 ladder
20 Club 6 on 2010 ladder
21 Club 5 on 2010 ladder
22 Club 4 on 2010 ladder
23 Club 3 on 2010 ladder
24 Club 2 on 2010 ladder
25 Club 1 on 2010 ladder
Round two
26 Gold Coast
27 Club 16 on 2010 ladder
28 Club 15 on 2010 ladder
29 Club 14 on 2010 ladder
30 Club 13 on 2010 ladder
31 Club 12 on 2010 ladder
32 Club 11 on 2010 ladder
33 Club 10 on 2010 ladder
34 Club 9 on 2010 ladder
35 Club 8 on 2010 ladder
36 Club 7 on 2010 ladder
37 Club 6 on 2010 ladder
38 Club 5 on 2010 ladder
39 Club 4 on 2010 ladder
40 Club 3 on 2010 ladder
41 Club 2 on 2010 ladder
42 Club 1 on 2010 ladder
Round three
43 Gold Coast
44 Club 16 on 2010 ladder
45 Club 15 on 2010 ladder
46 Club 14 on 2010 ladder
47 Club 13 on 2010 ladder
48 Club 12 on 2010 ladder
49 Club 11 on 2010 ladder
50 Club 10 on 2010 ladder
51 Club 9 on 2010 ladder
52 Club 8 on 2010 ladder
53 Club 7 on 2010 ladder
54 Club 6 on 2010 ladder
55 Club 5 on 2010 ladder
56 Club 4 on 2010 ladder
57 Club 3 on 2010 ladder
58 Club 2 on 2010 ladder
59 Club 1 on 2010 ladder
This is dangerous for low finishing clubs, namely Richmond. While Adelaide also has the potential to finish at the bottom of the 2010 barrel, they’re not considered to be a “struggling” team in need of rebirth. Richmond, on the other hand, is a different story.
Comparison can be drawn with the Carlton Football Club. A few years ago they were tripping over the bottom rungs of the ladder. However, with three years in a row of number one draft picks, they managed to grab Marc Murphy, Bryce Gibbs, and Matthew Kreuzer. These three men have become young superstars in the Blues’ infrastructure and their instalment has ensured Carlton’s growth and potential for consistent finals football.
In the past two years, Melbourne has scooped the top picks, adding Jack Watts and Tom Scully to their developing line-up. Now, with the 2011 season on the horizon, it should be Richmond’s turn. But it isn’t.
The effects? Prolonged struggle. By focusing all the attention on the new clubs, the long standing ones, the ones that have been with the AFL for over a hundred years, slip out of the limelight. Without a raft to float on, the Tigers will surely continue to sink over the next few years.
As a result, the primary aim of bringing in the two new clubs to boost the competition is completely undermined.
Ladder Positions: Collingwood (4th); Western Bulldogs (5th)
Last three games: Collingwood (lose/lose/win); Western Bulldogs (lose/win/win)
Favourite: Collingwood
My Tip: Western Bulldogs
The game of the round, between two finals heavyweights. Both of these teams are at similar positions in the season. They’re considered definite top eight finishers and potential top four finishers. Last time they met, Collingwood won by 36 points. I doubt the Bullies will give them the same satisfaction again.
Both teams are coming off unexpected losses against mediocre sides in round 10 and will be under the same mental pressure. The game will by won by the team that rises above the pressure and forces themselves back into the contest.
Collingwood, with its selection of small running forwards, has a potent attack, unbeatable up until their rounds 9 and 10 losses to Geelong and Brisbane respectively. The Western Bulldogs, on the other hand, devise a more conventional structure around their tall forward in Barry Hall. If he plays well, which he has been, and the Bulldog midfield deliver him enough of the ball, Collingwood will have a significant task on their hands.
In the spirit of balance and rounded equilibrium, I am tipping the Bulldogs to get one back on the Pies in 2010…
Ladder Positions: Hawthorn (11th); Port Adelaide (10th)
Last three games: Hawthorn (win/win/win); Port Adelaide (lose/lose/lose)
Favourite: Hawthorn
My Tip: Hawthorn
Port Adelaide has fell far from form. Two of their last three losses were against low level teams in Melbourne and Richmond. It is a team who has the capacity to do great things, but a team who often fall short of the expectations they build.
Hawthorn... are no different.
On paper, I can’t see Hawthorn going down. With stars like Mitchell, Franklin, Hodge, and Roughhead, they’ve got the credentials to win against any team in the competition. However, this week they’ll have to do it without their star forward in Franklin, who was given a week suspension for a high bump in round 10. Like he often does, it would be good to see Roughhead stand up in Franklin’s absence and kick a bag to drag his team over the line.
Hawthorn should win...
Last three games: Sydney (lose/lose/lose); Essendon (win/win/win)
Favourite: Sydney
My Tip: Sydney
Essendon are in stellar form. They’ve won their last three games, two of which were against St Kilda and the Western Bulldogs. After being subjected to close scrutiny early on in the season, coach Matthew Knights has managed to turn his group into a dangerous mid-season force. However, the big question to ask is how long can good form from a mediocre team last? Similar teams in Carlton and Hawthorn have the same curse of being able to beat the best teams one week, only to lose to the worst teams the week after.
That’s not to say that Sydney is by any measure a bad team. They had a genuine start to the season, with firing form from key new recruit Daniel Bradshaw. With news that 2010 will be coach Paul Roos’ last, many expected the Swans to rile up and pay a finals tribute to the longstanding premiership leader. However, that expectation has been significantly tempered of late with an injury to Bradshaw that has marked a dramatic drop in team form.
The win will be important for both groups in order to really establish themselves as 2010 finals contenders. The home ground advantage will help to tip Sydney into gear and I think it will be enough to get over the line against a historically inconsistent Bombers.
Ladder Positions: Geelong (1st); West Coast (14th)
Last three games: Geelong (win/win/win); West Coast (lose/lose/win)
Favourite: Geelong
My Tip: Geelong
There isn’t much to say; to tip an upset here is a gutsy tip to make. Fremantle and West Coast are renowned for their ability to rise to the occasion when they play in front of a Subiaco crowd. Evidence of this came early in round three when the Dockers played to the Subiaco advantage and broke the spirits of a confident Geelong outfit. However, West Coast is no Fremantle and Geelong is perhaps even stronger now than they were then.
The controversy surrounding West Coast coach, John Worsfold, and the talks of his forced retirement will have one of two effects on the Eagles: they’ll come to the defence of their long standing premiership coach and create a staggering upset; or they’ll fold to the pressure and succumb to the classy Cats.
While the first will give me something to write about post match, I doubt the struggling West Coast outfit have it in them.
Ladder Positions: Brisbane (9th); North Melbourne (13th)
Last three games: Brisbane (win/lose/lose); North Melbourne (lose/lose/win)
Favourite: Brisbane
My Tip: Brisbane
This game I think is more important for Brisbane. After a five game losing streak, they managed to deter the swooping Magpies last week at the ‘Gabba. Standout performances came from Luke Power (in his 250th game), Simon Black, Daniel Rich, Johnathon Brown, and Brendan Fevola. These five men are the big names at Brisbane; when they rise the Lions are tough to beat. While they all won’t need to rise again to defeat a struggling North Melbourne side, Coach Michael Voss would take pleasure in seeing his two gun forwards get back to their early season form.
North Melbourne has been a struggling club for some time now. They’ve had difficulty with membership and game attendance, which is largely due to their inability to stage themselves as a genuine finals contender. However, new coach Brad Scott has something to play for this weekend as he takes on his old playing club, and some of his old team mates in Brisbane.
After a long time in injury, Drew Petrie returned to the Roos last week only to be carried back to the “indefinite list”. Jarred Brennan, who has been missing in action from the Lions for several weeks with an ankle injury, will make his return after undergoing a “miracle” recovery.
To ensure they stay on track for this year’s finals, the Lions will be tough to beat this weekend and should get over the line…
Last three games: Adelaide (lose/win/lose); Fremantle (win/lose/lose)
Favourite: Fremantle
My Tip: Adelaide
This game holds significant importance for both clubs. For Fremantle, who equally lead the competition with Geelong, a win will ensure they keep their place at the top and put them merely two games from meeting the mathematical requirement for finals. Adelaide will be celebrating the last career game of one of the clubs longest standing and premiership players, Tyson Edwards.
Fremantle has something to gain. Adelaide has something to lose. Both teams will want to take what is theirs.
Adelaide had a woeful start to the season and any chance of playing finals in 2010 is lost. Fremantle, defying all external expectations, have given them all the chances to play in and win a premiership in September.
Although it may be a risky tip, I think Adelaide will rise higher to the occasion. The crowd will be full, the emotions will be high, the contest will be fierce.
Last three games: Carlton (win/lose/win); Melbourne (lose/win/lose)
Favourite: Carlton
My Tip: Carlton
Melbourne’s in-form start to the season has all but slowed to a halt. A severe bout of inconsistency has quelled any hope that they might be a 2010 finals contender. Last week’s outing at Skilled Stadium merely revealed the gaping distance between them and the quality sides like Geelong.
Carlton are equally known for their inconsistency—an ability to take down the best sides in the competition one week only to stumble over the bottom rungs of the ladder a week later. However, their young list shows extensive promise and they can be almost assured a finals campaign in 2010.
With a home crowd advantage, the Blues should be far too good from the Demons on Saturday afternoon. With some initial opposition last week, Chris Judd and his men ran over the heads of a weak West Coast Eagles side last weekend to further install some faith in their heavyweight credentials.
With Melbourne’s inclusion of Matthew Bate this weekend, they should have some class in the midfield, but it won’t be enough.
Last three games: St Kilda (win/win/lose); Richmond (win/lose/lose)
Favourite: St Kilda
My Tip: St Kilda
At the end of the 2009 season, the Saints were minor premiers and Richmond was the runner-up for the wooden spoon. After ten rounds, the Saints had won ten games to Richmond’s two.
At the midway point in the 2010 season, both teams have wavered in success. St Kilda has won 7 from 10 to keep them comfortably in the top four, while Richmond has just managed the one win against Port Adelaide in round nine.
On paper, the game’s outcome is predictable enough. Although the Saints haven’t sufficiently backed up from their 2009 success, they should nevertheless be feared as a serious finals contender. The hunger should still be burning and their ability to close down these low level games needs to be in tune to maintain a healthy opportunity in 2010.
The last time these teams met was in round 13, 2009; the Saints won by 56 points. The difference? Justin Koschitzke kicked five majors, while Jack Riewoldt kicked one goal, four behinds.
In lies the challenge to Jack (Riewoldt) and Richmond. Without cousin Nick parading the Saints’ forward fifty, responsibility again lies heavily on Koschitzke. So far in 2010, Jack has averaged 2.9 goals a game to Koschitzke’s 0.7. In rounds 9 and 10, Jack kicked four and six goals respectively. While I’m not suggesting that the hopes of either team rests solely, or even slightly, on the shoulders of these opposing men, statistics don’t lie and good form is perennial.
However, in that same breath, team form far outweighs player form and it would be dangerous to assume that Richmond has hit “good” form merely because the club achieved their first win for the season.
While, for the sake of the competition, I hope the teams meet at a contest, I can only assume that the Saints will take the four points…
Tyson Edwards will play the last game of his longstanding career at AAMI Stadium on Saturday Afternoon, when Adelaide takes on Fremantle.
The farewell match comes amidst a cloud of controversy. It began when Edwards announced his immediate retirement after being demoted to the SANFL to regain his lagging form. Adelaide Coach Neil Craig took the news in his firm stride and initially refused to offer the club’s second longest standing player a farewell tribute game. However, backed by widespread support from the club fans and officials, the decision was revaluated and Edwards’ final run against the Dockers was approved.
Expectations of Edwards’ final game are high after the performance he manufactured in 2009 in his 300th game milestone, racking up 41 possessions in the Crows’ round 11 win over Essendon.
Edwards was drafted to the Crows in 1994 as a compact midfielder, and made his debut in 1995 against the Western Bulldogs. In his fifteen years for the Crows, he’s played 320 games, kicked 190 goals, and has been a part of two premierships.
Although his career was largely overshadowed by those of former team mates Andrew McCleod and Mark Ricciuto, Edwards will be remembered for his humble determination and effective contribution to every facet of the game.
AFL Insider wishes him well in his endeavours, footy related or otherwise.
Without Nick Riewoldt, can St Kilda still be regarded as a quality team and a genuine premiership contender, or is their playing structure so dependent on the presence of one player that they're likely to fall short of their 2010 finals goals?
Kevin Sheedy confirmed this afternoon in a press conference that Israel Folau is officially the newest recruit at the prospective Greater Western Sydney Football Club.
Sheedy, foundation coach of team GWS, spoke positively and with uncontained enthusiasm of the Folau deal, speaking of the twenty one year old's natural football abilities and athleticism.
The 195cm and 103kg Brisbane Bronco is the perfect size for AFL football, with the potential to fit in well in GWS's forward or back line structure. To draw some comparison, Brisbane Lions captain and superstar forward Johnathon Brown is an even 195cm and weighs 104kg.
How much the deal is worth has not yet been revealed, but reports suggest it is up to $1 million a season.
The confirmation of the Folau code switch comes amidst rumours that Gary Ablett is likely to negotiate a deal with the prospective Gold Coast Football Club at the end of the 2010 season.
Sometime today news will break that Israel Folau has become the newest recruit at the prospective Greater Western Sydney Football Club.
Floating rumours of the twenty one year old Brisbane Bronco's plans to switch codes were confirmed, somewhat tentatively, on "Before the Bounce" on Monday night.
Reports have it that the contract offered to Folao is worth around $1 million a season, a figure that would see the gifted rugby league player amongst the highest paid earners in the AFL.
While a switch of codes is seldom attempted, let alone achieved, the news comes almost a year after Karmichael Hunt made the same move, for a similar price, to the Gold Coast.
A related revelation is that Gary Ablett, who has been offered a lucrative multi-million dollar deal from the Gold Coast, has opted to postpone negotiations between he and the Gold Coast and he and his current club, Geelong, until the end of the 2010 season.
When asked about the future of his star midfielder, Geelong coach, Mark Thompson, refused to pass further comment. After some months of media saturation, the premiership coach is determined to focus on his current circumstances.
While many critics are adamant that the attempts from both emerging clubs to secure high profiles is a blind and dangerous ploy to generate hype and membership numbers, the bold recruiting has real potential to boost the image and support foundation of the game. Only time will tell.
Jason Akermanis is in serious risk of forced early retirement. After a slump in form and severe backlash from the media and Western Bulldog club officials after his outspoken comments on gay football players, Aker has fallen into a deep and sinking hole.
In his article to the Herald Sun on the 20th May, Akermanis spoke candidly on the issue of homosexuality in sport, namely AFL. In reference to the potential of a player “coming out” to his team mates and the football world, Akermanis said that “the world of AFL footy is not ready for it.
“To come out is unnecessary for a lot of reasons. Imagine the publicity associated with a current player admitting he's gay. It would be international news and could break the fabric of a club.
“Football clubs are very different environments. Locker room nudity is an everyday part of our lives and unlike any other work place. I believe it would cause discomfort in that environment should someone declare himself gay.”
The comments made headlines immediately, prompting quick responses from a number of AFL officials and coaches. The spot light then fell on Rodney Eade who assured the AFL that Akermanis would be reprimanded accordingly via a strict media ban and a hefty fine or suspension.
For Eade, whose team fell short to Essendon by nine points on the weekend, the issue is a matter of significant importance. While Eade made no suggestion that his team’s lack of form this weekend had any connection with the Akermanis saga, there is no denying that the Bulldogs’ veteran has brought unwanted attention to the club’s 2010 campaign.
However, it seems that negative publicity is the least of Aker’s worries, with the Brownlow Medallist experiencing a dangerous rut of bad form.
Eade made comment after the Bulldogs’ win over North Melbourne in round nine that Akermanis was struggling to develop consistency.
"Obviously Jason didn't play well on the weekend, but his previous two were OK, the Sydney game (the previous week) he was probably seven out of 10, so it was not too bad.”
So far in 2010, Akermanis has averaged 15.2 disposals, 4.7 contested possessions, and 10 uncontested possessions a game, and has kicked only two goals for the season.
"More to the point he's 33 now, he hasn't got the pace he had and there's not many players at 33 who have the pace they had.”
Perhaps it is time for Rodney Eade to heed his own justifications and recognize that Aker’s time is almost up. The Bulldogs’ current list is full of blaze and premiership potential and the next few years become vital to launching themselves into Grand Final History. However, football potential is a fizzling torch and Akermanis is a blowing wind.
Ordinarily, I would discount the Roos against Freo at Subiaco Oval. The Dockers have proven that in 2010 they are genuine premiership contenders. Under superstar captain Matthew Pavlich, their mix of young and old has proven to be an unpredictable and dangerous force.
However, round ten has revealed itself to be a week of upsets. The Bulldogs went down to Essendon at home; Port went down to Richmond at home; Collingwood fell to the Lions; and, Hawthorn was a narrow victor over the Swans.
By the book, I would give the nod to Fremantle…
By 27 points.
But in round ten, the underdogs are writing the book.
Throughout his career much has rested on their stern shoulders of Brownlow medallist Chris Judd. At West Coast, in his time as captain, he took the Eagles to two Grand Finals, claiming the flag in one. At Carlton, he remains the lifeblood of the team. As a captain he leads by example, with skill and courage. Today he takes on his old team in the Eagles. He has something to lose. He has something to gain. With talented youngsters by his side, he will be dangerous.
Hawthorn and Sydney go head to head at the MCG this afternoon at 1:10. While Sydney had a good start to the season, they’ve suffered a recent bout of loss to drop them back to seventh place on the ladder. While Hawthorn had a bad start to the season, they’ve enjoyed mild success to keep them in thirteenth, and perhaps give them a glimmer of opportunity to strike the top eight barrier.
I hope and predict the game to go down to the wire. Both teams need a win. Both teams will play for the win.
The Brisbane Lions pushed, poked, and prodded their way through to a narrow victory over the Pies at the Gabba on Saturday night.
The weather was perfect for perfect footy. An unbiased spectator, I sat amongst the haze of black and white of the Collingwood Army. It was boisterous: every squandered kick, every near goal, every poor umpire call was lamented in tune. When goals were scored and decisions went in favour, the Army erupted.
By the final siren, there was silence. A voiceless array of black and white stripes.
The Lions were relentless. While they only enjoyed a short lead— albeit the one of sole importance—they stayed with fingers outstretched for the entire four quarters. When Didak dropped a sideways footy onto the boot and wobbled it through, Rich went and did the same. When Didak did it again… Rich did it again.
The young blood pulsed through Brisbane like it did in the 2001-2004 Golden Era. When the run came, it came quickly and on fresh toes. When the goals came, they dropped from experienced hands to trusted boots.
Fevola starred in the fourth quarter, with another freakish goal, this time over his shoulder. Brown quelled any doubt that he was recovering well from recent injuries to the lower abdomen. In my pre-match article I said that the big forward duo would have to kick eight between them to win the game. They did just that.
There may be some woe for Johnathon Brown, seemingly being reported for his scuffle with Harry O’Brien. It seems that hair pulling is a popular, but sure fire way, to get the nod to tribunal.
For Luke Power, who enjoyed the win on his 250th game, victory is sweet.
St Kilda has fallen short of some of the expectations cast upon them at the start of the 2010 season. With the untimely injury of captain, Nick Riewoldt, the Saints have suffered an unnerving levelling of form. To be a genuine contender for this year’s premiership, they will need to prove their worth as a playing group, and not merely a team that relies solely on the strength and fitness of their star player.
Adelaide, has similarly fallen by the wayside in terms of season expectations. After an exceptional season in 2009, the Crows have only managed to notch two wins on the Bailey in 2010.
Both teams will need to control the game according to their own methods of play. Whichever group manages to do this and sustain it will take the four points.
With their recent experience and dominance, I’m tipping the Saints…
Collingwood and Brisbane have had an interesting decade. In 2002 and 2003 they met in the Grand Final—Brisbane taking the flag on both occasions. For Brisbane then, it was the era of the Fab Four—Akermanis, Black, Lappin, and Voss—regarded as the greatest midfield group of all time. Their forward line structure—Brown, Lynch, and Bradshaw—was an unstoppable wrecking force. They were young, they were talented, they were the bench mark.
In 2010, we’ve reached a new era. Geelong has become the new “Team of the Decade”, and Collingwood again are the near favourite underdogs. Many tout them as premiership favourites, or at least worthy contenders. They’re young, they’re talented, they seek to define a new benchmark.
Tonight, the Lions and the Pies come together again. Tonight, there is no Fab Four. Akermanis is at the Bulldogs, giving lectures on group bonding and shower etiquette; Lappin has found a comfortable coaching role at Geelong; Black and Power are fighting on, but their days are numbered. Tonight won’t be won on reputation.
For Brisbane to win they’ll need to hit hard. Collingwood’s list is far more impressive. Their running forwards are a dime a dozen and their defensive line is one of the strongest in the competition. They have pace and skill and an ability to control the ball with mechanical precision.
Brisbane is plagued with injury. Their backline is raw and open to weakness. Their forward line on paper is one of the best in the league, but with drops in form from Brown and Fevola, it’s becoming a wavering standard.
The comeback kings will need to do what they do best: defy the odds. Without at least eight goals from the Brown/Fevola duo, the game will be beyond reach. Collingwood will need to keep their heads level and their inside 50s count.
Essendon have quelled any sudden plans for the Western Bulldogs to break into the top four. By a nine point upset the Bombers crashed the party at Etihad Stadium, stringing together their third win on the run.
Final Score—
Essendon: 15.9.99
Bulldogs: 14.6.90
Next week the Bombers take on Sydney at the SCG and the Western Bulldogs meet Collingwood at Etihad Stadium. Preliminary tips: Sydney over the Dons by 10; Bulldogs over the Pies by 5.
I've followed the site for months now and think it's great. I think they stopped running it for a while but it seems to be back on. Get involved-- some of the stuff is really funny and quite catchy.
I think the point of it is to just write one liners about the events of the week, but they do it really well. Have a look at some of the past comments. I hope they continue this now so I don't look the fool plugging it.
The Brownlow Medal is widely considered the greatest individual accolade in AFL football. To win one puts you amongst the best in history. To win two puts you amongst the elite. To win three puts you amongst the untouchables. Two win four... is unheard of.
The honour, usually reserved for the classy and audacious midfielders, is awarded by the field umpires, who designate votes to the best players of each round. The votes are tallied and the winner is announced in the week leading up to the Grand Final.
Last year Gary Ablett, arguably the greatest footballer of his generation, finally accepted his medal for a stellar 2009 campaign.
I'm tipping Lenny Hayes for 2010. He's been in the system for over ten years (around the time Nathan Buckley won his) and has been touted for his consistency and hardness at the contest. This year especially, with the inaction of Nick Reiwoldt due to a serious hamstring injury, Hayes has stood up to St Kilda captaincy and has become an important lifeline, not only in the midfield but across the ground.
Please, cast your own opinion as to who it will be this year...
I discounted Melbourne last week against the Power and they ended up winning by a point in a thriller in Darwin. Although it’s a bold move, with the chance of being embarrassed twice in two weeks, I’m going to do the same again. Richmond, although showing some strength in form and spirit in 2010, have so far failed to convert their opportunities. I doubt they can do just that this week against a good side in Port, especially at AAMI stadium.
I can’t imagine this contest being very contested. In Darwin, where does the advantage lie? Melbourne has somewhat reborn their existence in 2010, but I doubt it will be enough to take down the strength of the Port Adelaide line-up.
Tim Ruffles will become Fremantle's 10th debutant of the season and its ninth first-year player to be unveiled when the club meets Adelaide at AAMI Stadium on Saturday night.
Ruffles, 18, will be joined by Dean Solomon, who has served a club-imposed one-match ban, while injured captain Matthew Pavlich (calf) won't be risked but will still travel with the side for a match-day role.
Coach Mark Harvey said with 16 players unavailable for selection, including rookies, he didn’t have the luxury of resting draftees Stephen Hill and Nic Suban and would continue the club's aggressive youth policy by selecting Ruffles.
"He’s been playing really well at WAFL level for a month now, so it gives us the opportunity at selection to put his name forward and play him," Harvey said from Fremantle Oval on Wednesday afternoon.
"When you have 14 new players and you have substantial injuries then it can be forced upon you a little bit, but I think we’ve got to be brave with selection and know where we’re heading."
Ruffles, who Fremantle recruited with pick No. 68 in the 2008 NAB AFL Draft, has been used as a forward by WAFL club Perth and has averaged 16 possessions and two goals in his last month.
Harvey said he would play the New South Welshman on a wing and in attack, but would eventually like to have him on the ball.
"(He's) lively, he’s got some speed and acceleration and a good leap on him," Harvey said.
"He needs to evolve in his body too, but he’s just elusive when he plays."
Harvey made the announcement in front of all his players on Wednesday and said it was one of the moments he treasures as a coach.
"Just the glee and him being ecstatic, not knowing that was coming in front of the group," he said.
The Brisbane Lions were the last side to debut 10 players in one season, in 2006, after giving opportunities to 11 in 2005.
This year, Richmond and North Melbourne have each played seven debutants for a total of 37 games while Melbourne has debuted six.
Fremantle's nine new players have combined for 53 games.
Luke Pratt, a second-year elevated rookie, has been joined by draftees Hill, Suban, Hayden Ballantyne, Zac Clarke and Michael Walters and rookie-listed trio Greg Broughton, Matt de Boer and Clancee Pearce.
Geelong has taken a giant step away from the disappointment of September's grand final loss and sent an ominous warning to the rest of the competition, thrashing Collingwood by 76 points to claim the NAB Cup at Docklands on Friday night.
The Cats last won the pre-season premiership in 2006 and looked certain to claim this one from midway through the second quarter.
Scores were locked at the first change but six unanswered goals generated a 40-point lead at the main break and laid the foundations for the 0.18.19 (127) to 1.6.6 (51) victory.
Joel Selwood, who with Gary Ablett wreaked havoc through the midfield, won the Michael Tuck Medal as the best player on the ground.
So dominant were the Cats in what was expected to be a close contest, that the Pies took almost a half of football to kick their third goal of the game. It came at the 13-minute mark of the third quarter.
So imposing were they in almost every match-up around the ground that acting captain Cameron Ling was substituted from the game in the third quarter.
But the news wasn't all good for Geelong, with premiership defender Josh Hunt taken from the ground on a stretcher in the first quarter with what is suspected to be an ACL injury to his left knee.
He hit the ground after an innocuous clash with Collingwood forward Paul Medhurst.
Selwood was stellar, collecting 19 touches to half time to finish with 33 and two goals. Ablett was less visible but no less effective, especially in the last term, and had 35 disposals and three goals.
Paul Chapman (29 possessions, two goals) was also very good while young forwards Tom Hawkins and Ryan Gamble were lively but wasted opportunities.
Harry Taylor clearly won his battle with Travis Cloke and Matthew Scarlett, Corey Enright and Darren Milburn were watertight as usual.
The free-kick count heavily favoured the Cats (27-10) but despite the moans of Pies fans, it accurately reflected the winners' desire to be first, strongest and smartest at the contest.
For the Magpies, Shannon Cox stood out with 17 generally good disposals, Scott Pendlebury (14) and Dane Swan (16) worked hard in the midfield, Thomas showed flashes of form forward, while Tarkyn Lockyer was reliable as a backman.
The Cats got off to a great start when Tom Lonergan booted their first after a free kick was awarded right in front, but the Magpies then kicked three of the next four to take back the lead.
One of those was a 50m penalty won by ruckman Chris Bryan for a nine-point conversion, but Selwood was able to reply.
The Cats then turned it on in the second, adding 6.5 to 0.1. Steve Johnson kicked the first before Chapman took a Selwood handball to goal on the run. Varcoe then kicked his first and Selwood nailed another.
Johnson marked unmanned 30m out and converted and then Ablett sent home a super-goal that was disallowed because of an infringement in the square. He booted a regulation goal moments later to make up for it.
The Cats had several more opportunities on the way to their 40-point half-time lead, but didn't capitalise on them.
The third term started in similar fashion, with the Cats booting a couple before the teams traded majors. Fifty-six points clear, the Cats turned for home.
In the last, Ablett kicked an incredible goal from 40m on the boundary only for the Pies to find a double through Thomas and Cloke.
Geelong then booted the last four, including Jimmy Bartel's celebrated say after the final siren.
The focus of both sides will now switch to round one of the season proper, with Geelong to meet Hawthorn in two weeks' time and Collingwood hosting Adelaide.
Hawthorn coach Alastair Clarkson tried to put the attention on to his team but it was all about that man – Lance Franklin – after his star spearhead made an emphatic return to senior football on Friday.
Playing his first game of the pre-season at Visy Park, Franklin gathered 26 disposals and booted 4.4 to help his side power away from the West Coast Eagles.
The two teams were level for most of the day before ‘Buddy’ helped the Hawks boot 5.5 to 1.0 in the final term as his team ran away to win by 38 points.
Despite some poor kicking from both teams, Hawthorn won what was at times a scrappy affair, 13.21 (99) to 8.13 (61).
“We were pretty pleased with what [Franklin] was able to put out today,” Clarkson said after the match.
“He’s done a lot of training; he hasn’t done a lot of contact work over the summer but he’s been able to do a lot of the running work and in the last three or four weeks he’s built up his body contact.
“So he’s ready to go; he’s fit and hungry and he’s had a good pre-season but he just had less body contact and marking contests in pre-season than what he would have in the last three years, but that’s not such a bad thing.”
While Franklin played almost the full four quarters, Hawks star Luke Hodge also made a successful return.
He gathered 19 possessions in his now-customary role across half back. The Norm Smith medallist, with his right shoulder heavily strapped, did not return after three-quarter time and had ice on his left thigh, but Clarkson said Hodge had only copped a minor knock and his team had got through the clash relatively unscathed.
While Hodge went about his work in usual, mopping-up fashion, Franklin was more conspicuous.
Whenever he got the ball, the small crowd could be heard lifting their voices in anticipation – particularly later in the match as the No.23 began to exert a greater influence.
He showed on several occasions the shoulder and thumb injuries that had hampered his summer were behind him as he took several strong marks and moved with his usual zip.
He also showed little regard for Eagle opponents Mitch Brown and, for the most part, Eric Mackenzie, often playing on and taking on his less experienced rivals.
Franklin finished the day with four goals but also had a hand in at least three others.
Jarryd Roughead also provided a strong target, while at ground level there were no sign of the second-year blues for Cyril Rioli, who pounced on anything loose and looked lively throughout the match.
Brad Sewell was on and off the ground throughout the game but was his usual bullocking self when on the ball. He, along with skipper Sam Mitchell, each had 29 disposals.
Clarkson was also pleased with the performances of youngsters Ryan Schoenmakers, Beau Dowler, Garry Moss, Brendan Whitecross and rookie Riley Milne.
With the Hawks not having any injury concerns from the match, the club will now focus on which players they have to choose from for their round one clash with Geelong.
Clarkson said Trent Croad and Rick Ladson were certain to miss but the door was ajar for an influx of others to push for a recall against the Cats.
“Jordan Lewis will be an outside chance … we’ll need to make an assessment on [Stephen] Gilham,” he said.
“No matter what happens we’ll have a good competitive side that runs out there for round one.”
Dream Team watch – Hawthorn’s Lance Franklin is rated a $428,000 forward in Toyota AFL Dream Team 2009.
Jordan Lisle - In Rolls Jade
Might roll into his new club as a first round pick, possibly to Hawthorn, and be used in the same position as Rawlings was.
Nick Heyne - Cheeky Inn
Might be best to stay away from there and concentrate on preseason training.
Stephen Hill - Lent His Help
He will help any club that drafts him.
Lewis Johnston - Shown In Jostle
Might be a physical player in a few years.
Mitch Robinson - Hot Crimson Bin
Wherever he goes, it is likely to be hotter than where he is from.
Rhys O’Keeffe - He Offers Key
May not be the key to a premiership, but still a useful contributor.
Ashley Smith - Seal His Myth
At draft camp, his numbers were not a myth.
Dayne Beams - Many See Bad
Plenty see some good upside too.
Tom Hill - Toll Him
If the Saints draft him, he could spend a lot of time on the new toll road.
Zachary Ledin - Nicely Hazard
Something to do with the Dukes and The General Lee.
Tom Allwright - Grow That Mill
Clubs would draft him higher if he did grow a bit taller.
Bart McCulloch - Calm Torch Club
Seems like a calm player.
Dylan Ross - Sold Yarns
Might fit in with the fabric of his new club.
Peter Rolfe - Flee Report
Doesn't seem like the player to get reported very often.
Matthew Martin - Tan Emit Warmth
Sunscreen is important when training during summer.
Michael Gugliotta - Tough Magical Tile
Not really tough, or magical, but a good prospect.
Xavier Gotch - Grave Ox Itch
Must have something to do with Schwarz.
Liam Shiels - Hails Slime
Ghostbusters was a good movie.
Adrian Williams - Win A Similar Lad
Clubs have similar players to Williams to pick instead of him.
Peter Summers - Supreme Terms
If he does get a chance again at the AFL, his contract terms won't be that good.
Jarrad Blight - Right Bald Jar
Might be a blight on anagrams.
Daniel Murray - Many Ruled Air
Has the height to rule the air.
Steven Motlop - Sent Plot Move
The Power may have sent word of their plot to draft him.
Will Martiniello - Will Iron All Time
Should keep his new uniform in pristine condition.
Brodie A’Vard - Drive Abroad
If he doesn't get drafted there is the VFL or an overseas driving vacation.
Charlie Sharples - Sharper Achilles
Sharper is probably a good thing, at least better than dull.
Tyson Mihocek - Money So Thick
That does happen to players that get drafted.
Ryan McKenzie - Knee Zinc Army
That doesn't make sense.
Tyson Slattery - Yet Only Starts
Might start on the ground, but see plenty of the bench.
Dylan McNeil - My Inn Called
Ready for a holiday if a club doesn't call his name on draft day.
Brett Goodes - Good Betters
His brother is very good, and Brett is unlikely to be better than him.
Todd Grima - Got Madrid
Also had the VFL and SANFL.
Jaye Bowden - We Enjoy Bad
Players can learn from defeats.
Sam Wright - Swam Right
A multi-position footballer, might be a multi-sport athlete too.
Lance Daly - Any Called
A few teams have called and are interested in drafting him.
Mitch Frail - Him Lift Car
Doesn't look strong enough to do that yet.
Some of the prospects who didn't have enough letters, or the right ones, to make useful anagrams:
Jack Watts
Jack Ziebell
Tom Swift
Jamie Sheahan
Jay Shannon
Kade Klemke
Luke Shuey
Zach Sengstock
Sam McGarry
Tom Simpkin
Jordan Jones
Bryce Carroll
Scott Blesing
Adam Varcoe
Alistair Smith
Orren Stephenson
Ben Bucovaz
Music That Will Guarantee A Win
Melbourne could beat Hawthorn, if they watched this before the game.
Fremantle will go to Geelong next season and defeat the Cats, if they can be inspired by this.
The umpires might watch this before they run onto the field.
The site will undergo an offseason hiatus, please go to the AFL site and AllFooty.Info for news on the draft and other football information.
It seems that hair and fame are sometimes more important than results, and there is nothing wrong with that. They only had that one really great year when they reached the top, but it was a big year and is still talked about today.
Sydney - Van Halen
Always changing their frontman, but still having success.
West Coast - Motorhead
It's a surprise that some members are still performing.
Western Bulldogs - Screaming Jets
Keep hanging around but struggle to fill the larger venues.
Van Halen, they have shown that even if a lead singer is fired in an angry dispute that there is a good chance they will return to the band in the future. You Really Got Me - Van Halen
Both have gone a bit soft despite being at the top in the past.
North Melbourne - Krokus
They have a few fans, who are loyal and loud, but there isn't a big rush for tickets when they go on sale.
Port Adelaide - Slayer
Can play at a fast and frenetic pace.
Richmond - Whitesnake
Their fans are happy to see them perform, but their best work was quite a while ago.
It is metal Michael Bolton, he could have been the King Of Hair Metal but decided to instead turn down the volume and he made plenty of money playing to a new crowd. Everybody’s Crazy – Michael Bolton
It was more about the person in charge. The identity for more than the past two decades was all about one individual, which means Essendon are in some trouble as they try to find a new direction.
Fremantle - Deep Purple
They both like purple.
Geelong - Slade
While appreciated by many, it seems that their fans from the local area are the ones who are really fanatical about what they do.
Hawthorn - Metallica
Most thought that their best work was a decade or two ago, but have made an impact again recently.
Twisted Sister, Dee Snider was the main reason for their success, that and their funny music videos. I Wanna Rock – Twisted Sister
They had a lot of success in the past, and still fill venues because of it. They are very even, nobody really does more than the next person and there isn't one superstar that takes the spotlight away from the others, but they have success and it is in part because of that.
Brisbane - Guns N' Roses
They came into being due to a merger, which was more of a takeover. At their peak they were very successful, but now there is always the chance that they could disappear. Without their frontman, they could be in trouble.
Carlton - Winger
Their frontman gets all the attention, and seems to be a bit opinionated and rude, but they are not as good as they tell everyone they are.
Collingwood - AC/DC
They could have one hit in the past few decades and still sell every seat at every venue that they play at. They also continue to play the same way year after year, even when they bring in someone new it doesn't change how they go about their business.
One day the guitarist will graduate from school, or maybe not. Heatseeker – AC/DC
The idea is to rearrange the letters in the possible draftees’ names to find a word or phrase that could describe them and how they play football. That doesn’t usually happen, but some interesting answers do appear. Below are some of the anagrams.
Today is all about people asking when there will be trades made, while earlier in the week it was about people asking who had actually won for best mark and goal of the year.
Here is another question, what happened to the sesquicentennial for Australian football?
A couple of TV commercials, a Melbourne versus Geelong game that started early so people could watch a fire being lit in a Chinese stadium, putting a 1 in front of the 50, is that all there was?
Maybe they could have released a list of the 150 greatest Australian footballers, covering all the leagues during that time. That would have educated people about the history of the game, and brought needed recognition for the past stars of many leagues and teams.
Not the most important area to address for football, but it still would have been good if some effort was put in to make the sesquicentennial more memorable.
1 Luke Hodge - Hawthorn
2 Luke Ball - St Kilda
3 Chris Judd - West Coast
4 Graham Polak - Fremantle
5 Xavier Clarke - St Kilda
6 Ashley Sampi - West Coast
7 David Hale - North Melbourne
8 James Bartel - Geelong
9 Luke Molan - Melbourne
10 Sam Power - Western Bulldogs
The 2001 "Super Draft" had a lot of super players in the top 10, and a few draft mistakes too. Three premiership players, three players called Luke, probably at least three busts, so good things and bad things come in threes in this top 10.
Hodge, Judd and Bartel all won with the teams that drafted them, and that is the definition of a successful pick. But for the Eagles, they no longer have the player they selected. The Cats and Hawks still have Bartel and Hodge and also a chance to win more premierships.
Hodge, Ball and Molan have probably been told, "Luke, I am your father." They don't have a lot else in common. Hodge is a top overall pick that won a premiership, Ball seems to be injured too often but when healthy he is one of the Saints' most important players, Luke Molan is just an answer to football trivia questions about players who went high in a draft but never did anything but a leg injury was one reason for this.
So Molan leads the busts from this top 10. Other contenders for being a draft bust are Power, Sampi, Clarke and Polak. Sampi is a definite bust. Power and Polak were busts for the teams that drafted them, X Clarke is another oft-injured Saint from this draft.
Hale has needed a few years to develop and is now a very imposing key forward. The Kangaroos made a good pick but had to wait for their big investment to achieve its potential, compared to the onballers in this top 10 who didn't take as long to make an impact.
That is the end of the top 10 rankings. The 2008 draft should provide enough talent to be one of the best ever, and in a few years it could be ranked in the top 5 of all the AFL drafts.
1999
1 Josh Fraser - Collingwood
2 Paul Hasleby - Fremantle
3 Aaron Fiora - Richmond
4 Matthew Pavlich - Fremantle
5 Leigh Brown - Fremantle
6 Damian Cupido - Brisbane
7 Danny Roach - Collingwood
8 Joel Corey - Geelong
9 Caydn Beetham - St Kilda
10 Luke McPharlin - Hawthorn
A very good top 10 for the 1999 AFL Draft, as the amazing quality of some of the picks more than compensates for a few who were busts.
Pavlich and Corey are close to being among the top 5 players in the AFL, Pavlich is certainly in the top 5. Joel Corey was judged by those at Geelong to be their best player this season, so that means he is up there with the very best. Josh Fraser is a top 5 ruckman. It was an acceptable pick up the top of the draft, going with the best tall prospect available.
Luke McPharlin probably makes it into the top 5 for the AFL's key defenders, although when it comes to the club that first drafted him he helped them more by being part of a trade for draft picks which turned into Hodge and Mitchell. Luke McPharlin was also one of the few "unknown" prospects of recent drafts, and that does add to the excitement of the drafts, but obviously those in the West didn't hide him well enough at the time. Hasleby will return from injury next season, and be back in the middle for the Dockers as one of their most important players.
Fiora and L Brown are probably in the journeyman category, and they can contribute to wins for their AFL clubs but are also capable of putting in performances that send them to the VFL to play. Fiora and Brown are not at the clubs that originally drafted them, and might move again this week.
The Saints, Magpies and Lions did not use their picks wisely. So Brisbane missed out on being an even better team than they were when they won three consecutive premierships, while Collingwood missed out on some help for when they played against the Lions in the big games.
There were great players that went in the top 10 of this draft, and also with later picks. The Cats picked Chapman and Ling with picks in the 30s. Essendon went with Hille at 40. Melbourne selected Bruce at 64, and a lot of teams want Ryan O'Keefe right now but in this draft they all let him go by until Sydney used pick 56 to draft him.
2004
1 Brett Delidio - Richmond
2 Jarryd Roughead - Hawthorn
3 Ryan Griffen - Western Bulldogs
4 Richard Tambling - Richmond
5 Lance Franklin - Hawthorn
6 Tom Williams - Western Bulldogs
7 Jordan Lewis - Hawthorn
8 John Meesen - Adelaide
9 Jordan Russell - Carlton
10 Christopher Egan - Collingwood
A simple idea for how to build winning team, with two early picks just draft two big forwards. Hawthorn are now at the top of the AFL, which is better than being top of the draft.
Franklin, Roughead and also midfielder Lewis are very important to Hawthorn, without them they don't win a premiership, so to say the Hawks did well in this top 10 is an understatement.
Deledio is a very good player, so it isn't like Richmond came out of the draft with nothing. Tambling actually improved a lot in 2008, he stopped tumbling like he used to and had a lot more of the football.
The Bulldogs have been afflicted with the constant unwarranted need to draft small. Like Deledio, Griffen is a very good player, but of course he isn't as good as Lance Franklin. The Bulldogs did go a bit taller with the oft-injured Williams, who they now believe could become the AFL's best "Franklin Stopper".
The other clubs drafting in this top 10 probably hear the word "bust". Meesen is now at Melbourne, and Adelaide don't seem to miss him. They actually used a couple of moves to turn Meesen into Moran, which is an improvement. Egan and Russell were not the best that Collingwood and Carlton could have done in this draft.
Trade week news and analysis is being posted at AllFooty.Info so visit there for all the trade week information, as well as a new mock draft after trade week moves the picks around.
2006
1 Bryce Gibbs - Carlton
2 Scott Gumbleton - Essendon
3 Lachlan Hansen - Kangaroos
4 Matthew Leuenberger - Brisbane
5 Travis Boak - Port Adelaide
6 Mitchell Thorp - Hawthorn
7 Joel Selwood - Geelong
8 Ben Reid - Collingwood
9 David Armitage - St Kilda
10 Nathan Brown - Collingwood
A lot of this draft is still about potential, but there are also some players who have already proven they will be among the elite of the AFL.
At the time, there was plenty of talk that if Joel Selwood had healthy knees he could be the top pick. Everyone now knows that is correct, and Geelong have a couple of trips to the Grand Final to show that Selwood was a great pick.
Gibbs, it must be said, was terrible in his first year of AFL. It can now be said, to the relief of those who picked him up the top of the draft, he has turned things around. Gibbs can get the ball a lot, and use it well, and Gibbs has also proven that he can go against other star midfielders and beat them. Boak was a bit of a suprise when the Power took him earlier than expected but he is delivering for them.
Leuenberger, Hansen, Reid and Gumbleton are still all about potential. It won't be long before Leuenberger is Brisbane's version of Dean Cox. Hansen seems to have settled into a defensive spot. Reid will probably step up when Rocca retires. Gumbleton has been injured a lot and has also signed a new contract so he should be a big part of their forward structure in the next year or two.
Thorp's problem was he was drafted by Hawthorn, who already have Franklin and Roughead. Thorp may need a trade, or a shift to the back line at the Hawks. Armitage's problem may be the coach at St Kilda. Armitage is kicking game-winning goals one week, and is a Casey Scorpion back in the VFL the next. In 2009, the Saints probably play him every week so he should get a chance to show if he deserved to be a top 10 pick.
The early rounds of season 2008 were all about Collingwood's Nathan Brown, how he was containing the AFL's star forwards but not getting a Rising Star nomination. Brown was also capable of kicking goals when switched to the other end of the ground. Collingwood did the correct thing when they went tall in this draft, and also for trading to get another top 10 pick to use.
It can take ruckman four years to reach their potential, and for key forwards in can be three or four years, so when this draft is looked at in a couple of years the results could be even better than they currently are.
The SuperCoach and Dream Team AFL fantasy games take a break now but there are a few other games to play.
There isn't anything for the NBL, as there barely is an NBL at the moment. Soccer fantasy isn't a lot of fun, as a 0 - 0 game doesn't provide many statistics, and soccer fantasy games don't bother counting diving, spitting or punching the referee.
For those who play SuperCoach, and go to the horse racing, there is now the Herald Sun TAB SuperStable game. SuperStable
Yahoo Sports have introduced a brand new live draft program, which provides a lot of information and also has a sound warning so you don't miss your pick. The NHL and NBA are going to start their seasons soon. NBA NHL
2007
1 Matthew Kreuzer - Carlton
2 Trent Cotchin - Richmond
3 Chris Masten - West Coast
4 Cale Morton - Melbourne
5 Jarrad Grant - Western Bulldogs
6 David Myers - Essendon
7 Rhys Palmer - Fremantle
8 Lachlan Henderson - Brisbane
9 Ben McEvoy - St Kilda
10 Patrick Dangerfield - Adelaide
It is too early to evaluate this draft, but the signs are looking good.
Everyone except the Bulldogs has a reason to be optimistic, and the Bulldogs still have a couple of years to see if their investment in Grant was the right thing to do. Henderson or McEvoy were expected to be considered at the Bulldogs pick, so the Bulldogs may have done the wrong thing. At least they went tall and that is something they should be commended for.
Kreuzer is a future superstar, even without waiting the three or four years that it takes for many ruckman to show what they can do. Kreuzer has height, skills, agility, co-ordination, running ability, kicks accurately for goal, but he was the top overall pick so it is expected that he will be good.
Palmer, Cotchin, Morton, Myers and Masten are all in their team's best 22 players. It won't be long before some of them are among the core group of stars at their clubs.
Patrick Dangerfield needs to have a big 2009, not for him but for the Adelaide people who didn't want Ebert.
2007 was also when the Hawks picked Rioli, just outside the top 10, so it was a great draft for many teams.
1997
1 Travis Johnstone - Melbourne
2 Brad Ottens - Richmond
3 Trent Croad - Hawthorn
4 Mark Bolton - Essendon
5 Luke Power - Brisbane
6 James Walker - Fremantle
7 Kris Massie - Carlton
8 Chris Tarrant - Collingwood
9 Chad Cornes - Port Adelaide
10 Shane O'Bree - Brisbane
Cornes won with the team that drafted him, so did Power in Brisbane, and after a trip to Fremantle sorted him out even Trent Croad became a premiership player for the club that originally drafted him. So more than a few clubs found success in the top 10 of this draft.
Ottens also won, but not with the club that originally drafted him. Tarrant and O'Bree were good for the Magpies, although Tarrant is now a Docker and O'Bree started his career in Brisbane. Johnstone is now in Brisbane. Walker and Massie had long AFL careers, so they were not draft busts, Massie did his best work after going to the Crows.
Out of everyone from this very successful top 10, there were times when Mark Bolton seemed to get more things said about him than the other players selected. He was a Sheedy-favourite who didn't quite perform to the level expected, although there were times when the Bombers would name him to play the role of stopping Goodes and Bolton did play well in that role.
The Hawks had a lot of players that contributed to their Grand Final win. One who was very important when the game was in the balance was Stuart Dew.
Kicking 2 goals that gave the Hawks the momentum to get the win. Taking a very strong mark in the middle of the ground to stop dead a Geelong attacking move. Dew was in the right spot when it mattered during the biggest game of the year.
His stats included 2 goals and 1 behind, as well as 10 kicks, 9 handballs and 5 tackles.
It was a low-risk move by Hawthorn when they drafted Dew. Some in the media and at other clubs derided them for doing it but obviously they were wrong. He may have been a “Mountain Dew” but that is a good thing, as he used his size to run over players and his big leg to kick the ball longer than most other footballers.
The Hawks received the biggest reward possible from their investment in Dew and now he has premiership medals from two clubs.
2005
1 Marc Murphy - Carlton
2 Dale Thomas - Collingwood
3 Xavier Ellis - Hawthorn
4 Josh Kennedy - Carlton
5 Scott Pendlebury - Collingwood
6 Beau Dowler - Hawthorn
7 Patrick Ryder - Essendon
8 Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls - Richmond
9 Mitchell Clark - Brisbane
10 Marcus Drum - Fremantle
This draft wasn't too long ago, so the taller players get a pass because they should break through soon. Ryder has been a solid defender for a couple of seasons while Clark and Kennedy showed a lot of improvement in 2008.
The smaller players all get a pass, as do the teams that picked them. Ellis is a premiership player, Thomas and Pendlebury are the faces of a new Collingwood club and Murphy is an important piece of Carlton's talented midfield.
It seems to happen a lot, Fremantle didn't do too well out of a draft. Drum could have a breakout year in 2009 for the Dockers if he stays healthy. Richmond has also been known to draft poorly, and things are not looking good for JON. Dowler probably needs a move to a new club, or a move to the Hawthorn back line, to get playing time.
Right now, this draft is looking very good. In a few years, this top 10 could be one of the best.
2000
1 Nick Riewoldt - St Kilda
2 Justin Koschitzke - St Kilda
3 Alan Didak - Collingwood
4 Luke Livingston - Carlton
5 Andrew McDougall - West Coast
6 Dylan Smith - North Melbourne
7 Laurence Angwin - Adelaide
8 Daniel Motlop - North Melbourne
9 Kayne Pettifer - Richmond
10 Jordan McMahon - Western Bulldogs
The Saints were lucky that this was the year that they were terrible, as it set up their next decade by adding both Riewoldt and Koschitzke. The Saints should also be thankful that Riewoldt didn't live closer to Brisbane as he could have been playing for the Lions as a zone draft selection.
After the two star talls from the Saints, the draft provided people talented with the football but also with plenty of reasons why they should not be picked.
This draft also shows that when players get another chance at a new club they don't always take it. Motlop has been a success but others were not. McMahon was a draft mistake by the Bulldogs, and while it has only been a season and he may come good for them, it looks like he was a trade mistake by Richmond.
Excluding Riewoldt, no other player taken in the top 10 tried as hard as Livingston. He was an undersized full back on a poor team so it was always going to be difficult, he is doing much better when it comes to team success in the VFL.
This draft was when the Saints were given a chance to rebuild, they made the right choices with the top picks and importantly they went tall when they picked.
1994
1 Jeff White - Fremantle
2 Anthony Rocca - Sydney
3 Shannon Grant - Sydney
4 Scott Lucas - Essendon
5 Joel Smith - St Kilda
6 Robert McMahon - Fitzroy
7 Tony Brown - St Kilda
8 Daniel Harford - Hawthorn
9 Ben Wilson - Collingwood
10 Blake Caracella - Essendon
A lot of successful players in this top 10, but it also illustrates the dreaded "go home factor". The Dockers and Swans only rented the players they took in the top 3.
Essendon would be the happiest with the top 10. Lucas is a superstar tall forward who will spend his entire career with the Bombers. Caracella was also useful, but would be traded from Essendon towards the end of his career.
The Swans picked talented players but neither Rocca nor Grant lasted very long in Sydney. An expansion team is often not somewhere that players don’t want to be, and White went back east after a few years with Fremantle.
One star ruckman, two impressive key forwards, several quality midfielders, this is how a top 10 draft should look.
Ranking The AFL Draft Top 10s
1994
2002
1992
2003
1989
1993
1988
1998
1986
1996
1991
1995
1990
1987
It's not something you're likely to hear again after a hard-fought NFL game, but Eagles cornerback Sheldon Brown gave no hint that he was joking when he said, after the 15-6 victory over the Steelers, that punter Sav Rocca "won the game."
"They were unbelievable," coach Andy Reid said of Rocca's punts. "You don't very often talk about a punter being a weapon, but he sure was a weapon tonight."
Ben Graham wasn't a Jet one week, and was the next. The New York Jets did waive him but brought him back after their new punter hurt his leg.
The New York Jets re-signed recently released punter Ben Graham in time for him to play in the team’s Monday night game against the San Diego Chargers.
Graham was cut last Tuesday after getting off to a poor start in his fourth season with the Jets. New York signed journeyman Reggie Hodges to replace him, but Hodges injured his left thigh in practice late last week and was ruled out for the game at San Diego.
2002
1 Brendon Goddard - St Kilda
2 Daniel Wells - North Melbourne
3 Jared Brennan - Brisbane
4 Timothy Walsh - Western Bulldogs
5 Jarrad McVeigh - Sydney
6 Steven Salopek - Port Adelaide
7 Andrew Mackie - Geelong
8 Luke Brennan - Hawthorn
9 Hamish McIntosh - North Melbourne
10 Jason Laycock - Essendon
Maybe this shows that "good things come to those who wait". Patience with prospects is sometimes needed, but there can be big rewards.
Not too long ago, Jarrad McVeigh might have been considered a draft bust. At best he was a useful tagger, but not one of the first players picked each week by Sydney. Jarrad McVeigh has certainly stepped up his game and is kicking goals and getting a lot of the football in the middle.
The Kangaroos would have expected it could take several years for McIntosh to become a starting ruckman at AFL level. 2007 was his breakout year. The Bombers saw Laycock have a breakout game one Anzac Day, and not much else, but are still hopeful.
Brisbane is also being rewarded for being patient with J Brennan. They tried him as a forward, and in the back line and everywhere else, including the ruck, but it took him until last year to show that he wasn't a circus performer doing magic tricks with one hand. In 2007, he was helpful beside Brown, as Bradshaw was injured, and in 2008 he showed that with his size and mobility he could dominate in the centre. Hawthorn was not as fortunate with their Brennan, Luke Brennan.
Geelong was looking for help up forward when they drafted Mackie. He didn't impress there but has become a very exciting tall, running defender.
Salopek, Goddard and Wells are also still with the clubs that drafted them and are among the core group of players at those clubs. Something that is expected when a player goes in the top 10.
While there isn't a great superstar in this top 10, most clubs did make very good choices and are happy with the players they received.
Ranking The AFL Draft Top 10s
2002
1992
2003
1989
1993
1988
1998
1986
1996
1991
1995
1990
1987
A win is more likely if one team's important midfielder is contained and the other team gets some run and possessions from their players in the middle. Nick Dal Santo was made to look foolish by Chance Bateman, while Bateman provided plenty of dash for the Hawks and was over 20 possessions for the game.
The only idea that the Saints had that actually worked for getting Dal Santo away from Bateman was sending Dal Santo to the bench. Dal Santo had only 6 possessions in the first half, so Bateman did his job there when the game was won.
Bateman also had the ball himself with 12 kicks, 9 handballs and 6 marks. Sam Mitchell sent the ball inside 50 on 7 occasions, the only other player on the ground that also did that 7 times was Chance Bateman.
It could be hair versus no hair in the Grand Final if Bateman goes up against Ablett. That is where Hawthorn could get the win if Bateman can be as good in the AFL Grand Final as he was against the Saints.
1992
1 Drew Banfield - West Coast
2 Nathan Chapman - Brisbane
3 Michael Prior - Essendon
4 Justin Leppitsch - Brisbane
5 Jason Spinks - Sydney
6 Robert Pyman - North Melbourne
7 Wayne Hernaman - Richmond
8 Paul Symmons - West Coast
9 Martin Pike - Melbourne
10 Brett Chalmers - Collingwood
This might have been the draft that had many of the potential draftees writing to clubs telling them not to draft them. Probably not the best way to start a career in the AFL.
The Eagles made a solid choice. Banfield won at the start and at the end of his career. Not really the powerful key position prospect that should go up the top of a draft, but Banfield was a very productive player for the Eagles for many years.
Brisbane did find a key position player in this draft, Leppitsch was very good when played at either end of the field. Starting his career as a key forward, and ending it as their centre half back. Chapman might have also had key position height, but not the game.
Pyman would have been someone that Collingwood might have liked at pick 10, but he went earlier. He would get to Collingwood a few years later. The Magpies did draft Chalmers, which was not a good move.
Clubs did find future premiership players in this draft, and that is what they hope for when they make their draft selections.
Ranking The AFL Draft Top 10s
1992
2003
1989
1993
1988
1998
1986
1996
1991
1995
1990
1987
If it is the "midfielder's award", then Richardson is a chance for the Brownlow this year. He moved into the midfield, and the back line, while still getting forward often enough to kick plenty of goals.
Richmond didn't get a lot of wins, compared to the Cats, so the potential for 3 votes in many games going to Richardson is limited. The Cats will have to share the votes, and with Ablett missing games, Corey Enright having a big month in the middle of the season, and with Corey and Bartel and many more Cats deserving votes it is hard to see who their best will be.
Harvey has far fewer challengers at North Melbourne for votes, so he is the pick for the medal, but Matthew Richardson probably deserves it more than any others do.
A Geelong Brownlow trifecta, yet another potential piece of history for this machine of a football team, is a distinct possibility. Gary Ablett and Jimmy Bartel are first and second favourites, Joel Corey equal fourth, and Joel Selwood equal eighth in the betting.
2003
1 Adam Cooney - Western Bulldogs
2 Andrew Walker - Carlton
3 Colin Sylvia - Melbourne
4 Farren Ray - Western Bulldogs
5 Brock McLean - Melbourne
6 Kepler Bradley - Essendon
7 Kane Tenace - Geelong
8 Raphael Clarke - St Kilda
9 David Trotter - Kangaroos
10 Ryley Dunn - Fremantle
2003 was not a good time to be drafting. Cooney was considered to be the only prospect that had star potential, and that may have been proved correct. Everyone knew that Cooney would go with the top pick, and few had any idea who the other players in the top 10 should be.
If Melbourne could have measured the character of their possible picks, they would have taken someone different. If the Dockers and Saints would have known how injury-prone their players would be, they too would have looked for someone else. Ray, Bradley, Tenace and Trotter were also lacking in a skill or attribute that they were expected to have when they went in the top 10.
Walker is still mentioned with the word "potential". He may become a regular 20-possessions a game player, who also contributes in other ways due to his athleticism, but Walker will never be someone that a team builds around.
Short on talent, and also short when it comes to height except for Bradley, the 2003 top 10 isn't looking very good right now but maybe a few of the players listed start to turn things around soon. R Clarke is one who has lifted his play recently so there is still hope for others in the top 10 from 2003.
Ranking The AFL Draft Top 10s
2003
1989
1993
1988
1998
1986
1996
1991
1995
1990
1987
Supposedly it is back, Channel 7’s Footy Marathon. You can watch Benny Hill run around chasing people at 11:45pm and after that the TV guides say it is 8 hours of past Grand Finals.
The VFL Grand Final is also on the Friday night, on the ABC at 7:30 pm. Pay TV may be showing the TAC Cup Grand Final, from 4:00pm.
.
There used to be a time when Channel 7 had 3 Grand Finals to show on the Saturday, now they only have the big game. It looks like they will try to fill in 6 hours with a Daddo Family member, that can’t be good for ratings.
The Grand Final Marathon should be one of the highlights of the week, and showing in full the 1989 Grand Final is a must so hopefully 7 do that.
They didn't pay for a ticket for this game, they didn't sit in an allocated seat, some of them left before the game was over. No, this isn't about the MCC members, it's the flock of seagulls.
A Flock Of Seagulls
The night Grand Final is being pushed, by those who think they can make a bit more money out of it, but there are plenty of reasons against it. One of those has to be the seagulls. It has been said before and can be said again, and it also provides an excuse to play an odd music video, a night AFL Grand Final will be hampered by birds and slippery conditions. It can be guaranteed that tonight's game will have Dew on the ground.
Baseball game at night and birds take over.
The seagull infestation at the MCG does seem to be worse at night. Probably because during the day most seagulls are visiting the beach or a Kentucky Fried Chicken car park. During the Cats and Bulldogs game, it seemed the Williamstown VFL team was also on the field as there were a lot of seagulls. Sandilands was lucky he wasn't out there last night, as the birds were flying low enough they would have collided with him.
Roughead will always be in the shadow of Lance Franklin, not that it seems to worry him. It is much better to be the second star forward on a contender than get a lot of personal praise on a team that wins wooden spoons.
Opposition teams seem to forget that Roughead would be the main man at many teams, and he has shown that he can kick 5 goals in a game when teams don't respect his ability, or 5 goals in a quarter.
Roughead scoring 100 goals in a season, when Franklin does the same, is achievable. Maybe this could happen next year, or some time after that. Counting finals, he could play 25 games, 4 goals a game is only 1 per quarter, Roughead can do that. When Roughead and Franklin have the expansion teams to feast on in a few years, there could be some records broken in those games.
Franklin kicks a goal, with some help from Roughead.
A couple of years ago, a story was posted on this site detailing how Lance Franklin was the best young talent in the AFL then. He didn't reach the goals that were mentioned, he did even more than expected.
This might not be a good thing for Richmond supporters to see, as they missed out, twice. In the 2004 draft the top pick went on Deledio, pick 2 was Jarryd Roughead, pick 3 was a good choice with Ryan Griffen and Richmond was back again with pick 4 and Richard Tambling. Richmond didn't do too badly though, as Deledio is a star and Tambling may get there. Hawthorn should have taken him with 2 when he was available there, but they were lucky and at pick 5 they drafted Lance Franklin.
When Franklin was drafted he was listed at 196cm and 87kg. This season his weight was listed at 95kg, probably his perfect playing weight. This was not a Josh Thurgood case, this was a player with the potential to get stronger and that was achieved.
The developed Franklin is not only around 10cm taller than Brereton or Dunstall, but he nearly weighs as much as Dunstall did in his prime.
Now Franklin only has the potential to be as good as those two, but he is going in the right direction. In his first year he kicked a goal per game, in his second season Franklin had just over two goals per game. There is no reason why he can't get at least three goals a game for 2007.
He didn't improve just the total goals, and goals per game average, but it was also his accuracy from all distances and angles. He kicked behinds at the same average over both his first two years in the AFL, he increased his goals kicked per game so his accuracy in 2005 was 62% and for 2006 he improved to 78%.
If there is a problem, it is where he should be played. Franklin can play nearly anywhere so the question Hawthorn must answer is to find which spot he will do the most damage. Maybe they can put him alone in the goal-square and watch as he kicks 80 goals a season. But he doesn't have to be that close to score goals, Buddy is also one of the best shots for goal from outside 50m.
If there is a statistic that shows how underrated Franklin is, it is tackles. Last season he had a per game average that was higher than Crawford, Brown, Smith and Bateman. Lance was 8th on the Hawks for tackles per game, and the players who were ahead of him all played on the ball most of the time. Franklin might be tall but he is also fast, and this pressure on opposition defenses will create scoring opportunities.
If you have a player that you compare Franklin to then post a comment below, but in many ways he is unique. If you compare Franklin to other forwards he is either quicker or much bigger. Maybe Richardson comes closest, but Franklin is a decade younger than him. Riewoldt is another player to judge Franklin with, if Franklin had played the entire 2006 season he probably would have kicked as many goals as Riewoldt.
While comparing players to Franklin is difficult it is even harder for teams to find players to play on him. If they put a tall player on him Franklin will just run off them, if they try a faster opponent Franklin is too big for them.
Franklin ended 2006 with 3.25 goals a game over his last 4 games. If he keeps that going for 2007 that would equal 71 goals. An improvement on that would get him the Coleman, while 60 or 70 goals next season could get him on the All-Australian team.
Franklin would have started a bidding war among the AFL clubs if he had not signed a new contract. That he did agree to stay at Hawthorn means they have their most important piece in place and can build a contender around him.
If there is a better prospect, aged 21 or under, in the AFL then post a comment below.
Some agreed that Franklin was a superstar about to arrive.
He has the potential to become the complete player. A true utility that Hawthorn can use to roam freely and break games open at the blink of an eye lid.
All Hawthorn needs is a traditional link up half forward to come along and relieve Franklin of this responsibility. Perhaps that will be Roughead or it may be Sellar or Thorp pending this draft.
Don't get me wrong Deledio will be a superstar, but Buddy is something special!
wow I love buddy I wished we took him it the draft, There is so much natural talent, just wait till he learns to controll it. watch out he is going to be un believeable..
Some comments from then indicate that not everyone was sold on his future stardom.
The guy has had only 2 decent games to date. To be calling him a "Best young" is laughable.
Please not compare him to Dunstall or Brereton.
As a Hawthorn supporter I'd very much like to agree with your thoughts on Buddy, unfortunately to me he still lacks the marking ability and the decision making you're likely to get from an up and coming star. I hope he proves me wrong and kicks 80 odd in 07!!
Thats a joke....I'm sorry but 2 good games doesn't make you the best Player u/21, u's are all kidding yourselves and as a kangaroos supporter so im totaly unbiased in this comment but Brett Deledio is by far the best player in that age bracket, Brock is fantastic but he has no more improvement in him, what we see now is what we get with Brock.
Roughead talks.
Jim Rockford fills up his petrol tank for only $3, not even Franklin or Roughead can do that.
1989
1 Anthony Banik - Richmond
2 Matthew Croft - Western Bulldogs
3 Jody Arnol - St Kilda
4 Peter Matera - West Coast
5 Brad Rowe - Brisbane
6 Mark Brayshaw - Kangaroos
7 Stephen Edgar - Carlton
8 Brad Tunbridge - Sydney
9 Dale Kickett - Fitzroy
10 Daryl Groves - Collingwood
A lot of the other drafts mentioned so far didn't have a superstar go in the top 10. This one did, Peter Matera.
Although after Matera, the top 10 didn't include many other big names. Dale Kickett was a useful player for Fitzroy, and West Coast too, St Kilda as well, and Essendon, and did his best work at Fremantle.
The Bulldogs thought they were getting a key position player, but Croft was too short to be effective in that role. They still played him there, with little success.
Sydney went tall with their pick in the top 10, Tunbridge only lasted a few seasons but he was a big presence and produced a lot of hitouts.
Picks 11 to 20 in this draft went a bit better than the top 10, as some of the players selected included Gavin Wanganeen, Ben Allan, Nathan Bower and Gilbert McAdam.
Ranking The AFL Draft Top 10s
1989
1993
1988
1998
1986
1996
1991
1995
1990
1987
It seems that the one small area that needs improving at the Hawks is the amount of quality tall defenders they have. Roughead has played there before, and maybe he could go back there again permanently.
Franklin, Williams, Rioli, Boyle, Thorp and Osborne, they could provide enough goals to give the Hawks a winning score. Roughead, Croad and Gilham could take the tall defender positions and be assisted by Birchall, Guerra and Ellis.
It has happened before, one example is Brisbane with Leppitsch. A forward early in his career, he went to centre half back and helped them win premierships. Joel Bowden started as a forward before going to the back line. Leo Barry is another example.
Roughead could also be a trouble-shooter as his career progresses, playing as a forward one week and then going to the back line the next, depending on who the opposition is and what injuries the Hawks have to their tall players. McPharlin did some of that this season, while players like Pavlich, Waite, Bock and Hunter have also been used in that way over their careers.
If Croad or Gilham is injured, or the Hawks are playing a team with a lot of height up forward, or if they need to figure out a way to get Thorp into the side, maybe Roughead to the back line would work. It may be an odd idea now, as Roughead is very valuable and effective up forward, but that is what people thought the first time they saw Leppitsch go to the back line.
The Rockford Files. It looks like Jim Rockford's car was close to a Hawthorn colour.
The Box Hill Hawks went into its opening match with four new and exciting Hawthorn-listed names in its line-up. Rookie Ruory Kirkby, Jordan Lewis, Jarryd Roughead and Bo Nixon (against his former club) all made their Box Hill debuts. Williamstown selected many experienced VFL listed players including ex-Hawks Brad Lloyd and Rayden Tallis. 2004 Hawthorn rookie Paul Shelton was also named for the Seagulls.
The Box Hill forward line functioned like a well oiled machine in the first half. Key forwards Jarryd Roughead, Clinton Alleway and Tim Harvey severely tested the Seagull defence with their marking ability (Alleway and Roughead taking 16 marks between them) and all round aggression. Small forward Kristan Height did brilliantly in winning the contested footy (21 possessions and 6 marks) but let himself down with some missed chances in front of goal.
Apart from one season from Brad Ottens, Richo has never had a foil like Jarryd Roughead.
"Roughie" is precisely the buddy that Franklin needs along side him: a solid bloke with a lumberjack physique, who can't be budged. He's the rock on which the cult of Franklin will be built.
"Yeah, well, you get to play next to the guy who's arguably going to be the best bloke to ever play footy, and sometimes you get the second-best defender, so it's a win-win every week! You get a good view of watching Buddy do what he does and you have a good chance of beating your opponent," the less-profiled but no less valued member of Hawthorn's enviably talented duo of tall forwards says, before undertaking morning goalkicking practice in the lead-up to tonight's first final.
When they met as 15-year-old All-Australian representatives, Roughead and Lance "Buddy" Franklin liked each other instantly. As 21-year-old AFL teammates, they remain best mates despite the fact that as footballers, personalities and physical specimens, they are more yin and yang than peas in a pod.
"(It) was noticeable early in the game, Roughy had to sacrifice his position a fair bit, but that's what team play is all about," Clarkson said.
"As it turned out, they (the Bombers) were recognising that Franklin was making too great a contribution and that's when 'Roughy' started to kick his goals. He ended up with three, so that's what team play's all about."
Jarryd is very mobile and kicked 46 goals for the Gippsland Power in 2004. He is a fantastic one-grab mark, competitive and looks a superb talent.
Most of his 2005 season was spent in defensive roles, where it is hoped he will develop his football nous. Many believe his future lies in the front half of the ground.
The 2004 AFL Draft Results:
1. Richmond: Brett Deledio (Murray Bushrangers)
2. Hawthorn: Jarryd Roughead (Gippsland Power)
3. Western Bulldogs: Ryan Griffen (South Adelaide)
4. Richmond: Richard Tambling (Southern Districts)
5. Hawthorn: Lance Franklin (Perth)
6. Western Bulldogs: Tom Williams (Morningside)
7. Hawthorn: Jordan Lewis (Geelong Falcons)
8. Adelaide: John Meesen (Geelong Falcons)
9. Carlton: Jordan Russell (West Adelaide)
10. Collingwood: Christopher Egan (Murray Bushrangers)
11. Port Adelaide: Adam Thomson (Sturt)
12. Richmond: Danny Meyer (Glenelg)
13. Melbourne: Matthew Bate (Eastern Ranges)
14. Essendon: Angus Monfries (Sturt)
15. Melbourne: Lynden Dunn (Calder Cannons)
16. Richmond: Adam Pattison (Northern Knights)
17. St Kilda: Andrew McQualter (Gippsland Power)
18. Brisbane Lions: Cameron Wood (West Adelaide)
19.Port Adelaide: Ryan Willits (Northern Knights)
20. Richmond: Dean Polo (Gippsland Power)
21. Hawthorn: Thomas Murphy (Sandringham Dragons)
22. Western Bulldogs: Jesse Wells (Tassie Mariners)
23. Collingwood: Sean Rusling (West Adelaide)
24. Adelaide: Nathan Van Berlo (West Perth)
25. Carlton: Adam Hartlett: (West Adelaide)
26. Hawthorn: Matthew Little (Calder Cannons)
27. Brisbane Lions: Patrick Garner (Western Magpies)
28. Adelaide: Chad Gibson (Norwood)
29. West Coast: Matthew Rosa (North Ballarat Rebels)
30. Essendon: Andrew Lee (Tassie Mariners)
31. Sydney: Jarred Moore (Dandenong Stingrays)
32. Geelong: Brent Prismall (Western Jets)
33. St Kilda: Cain Ackland (Port Adelaide)
34. Port Adelaide: James Ezard (Calder Cannons)
35. Port Adelaide: Fabian Deluca (Eastern Ranges)
36. Richmond: Luke McGuane (Broadbeach)
37. West Coast: Mark LeCras (West Perth)
38. Western Bulldogs: Damian McCormack (Dandenong Stingrays)
39. Collingwood: Travis Cloke (Eastern Ranges)
40. Adelaide: Ivan Maric (Calder Cannons)
41. Carlton: Luke Blackwell (Swan Districts)
42. Kangaroos: Jesse W Smith (Calder Cannons)
43. Melbourne: Michael Newton (Murray Bushrangers)
44. West Coast: Mitch Morton (Claremont)
45. Brisbane Lions: Justin Sherman (Clarence)
46. Essendon: Henry Slattery (West Adelaide)
47. Sydney: David Spriggs (Geelong)
48. Geelong: Nathan Ablett (Modewarre)
49. St Kilda: Mark McGough (Collingwood)
50. Brisbane Lions: Jayden Attard (Dandenong Stingrays)
51. Port Adelaide: Benjamin Eckermann (Sturt)
52. Richmond: Dean Limbach (Calder Cannons)
53. Hawthorn: Simon Taylor (Box Hill Hawks)
54. Western Bulldogs: Stephen Tiller (West Adelaide)
55. Collingwood: Adam Iacobucci (Calder Cannons)
56. Adelaide: Chris Knights (Eastern Ranges)
57. West Coast: Bradley Smith (Subiaco, WAFL)
58. Kangaroos: Bradley Moran (Southport)
59. Fremantle: Benet Copping (Sturt)
60. Essendon: Paul Thomas (Adelaide rookie)
61. Sydney: Heath James (Sydney)
62. Geelong: Matthew Egan (Geelong, VFL)
63. St Kilda: James Gwilt (Noble Park)
64. Brisbane Lions: Luke Forsyth (Dandenong Stingrays)
65. Richmond: Mark Graham (Hawthorn)
66. Collingwood: Pass
67. Fremantle: Toby Stribling (North Adelaide)
68. Kangaroos: Ben Schwarze (Port Melbourne)
69. Fremantle: Daniel Haines (Fremantle)
70. Essendon: Pass
71. St Kilda: Pass
72. Richmond: Pass
73. Carlton: Chris Bryan (Frankston)
74. Kangaroos: Daniel Pratt (Brisbane Lions rookie)
75. Fremantle: Pass
76. St Kilda: Pass
77. Carlton: Anthony Raso (Dandenong Stingrays)
78. Carlton: Pass.
1993
1 Darren Gaspar - Sydney
2 Nigel Lappin - Brisbane
3 Justin Murphy - Richmond
4 Glenn Gorman - Sydney
5 Adam Heuskes - Sydney
6 Trent Cummings - Fitzroy
7 Chris Johnson - Fitzroy
8 Michael Frost - St Kilda
9 Rohan Warfe - Fitzroy
10 Trent Ormond-Allen - Melbourne
This may have been the first AFL draft that was televised live. What an event that was. The AFL draft needs to be put back on television, with a live show and a commentator who doesn't say that every pick is great.
Gaspar seemed to have nearly everything a top overall pick needed, except he couldn't kick the ball. He was a very good defender, and his unique hairstyle would have made David Hasselhoff jealous, but Gaspar isn't what a team should select up the top of the draft. Sydney also were not able to keep Gaspar for very long, and he would later join Richmond.
Lappin was a Bear that become a Lion, Chris Johnson was a Lion who would move north and still be a Lion later in his career. They were two good picks in this top 10.
Murphy achieved stardom very quickly with Richmond, and then disappeared from their team, after that he was traded around a few clubs.
It isn't really what a top 10 should look like, very few key position prospects, and zero ruckmen.
Ranking The AFL Draft Top 10s
1993
1988
1998
1986
1996
1991
1995
1990
1987
1 Brett Delidio Richmond
2 Jarryd Roughead Hawthorn
3 Ryan Griffen Western Bulldogs
4 Richard Tambling Richmond
5 Lance Franklin Hawthorn
6 Tom Williams Western Bulldogs
7 Jordan Lewis Hawthorn
Above is the actual order, but things could have easily been different then.
Deledio has talked about how he thought Roughead would be joining him at the Tigers. It might have happened, if the Tigers had taken Roughead first. The Hawks wanted size and may have taken Franklin at pick 2 while the Bulldogs have been reported to say that Griffen was who they wanted, even at pick 1. Of course, Richmond still miss out on Franklin, but would be improved with Deledio having Roughead to kick to up forward.
1 Jarryd Roughead Richmond
2 Lance Franklin Hawthorn
3 Ryan Griffen Western Bulldogs
4 Brett Delidio Richmond
5 Richard Tambling Hawthorn
6 Tom Williams Western Bulldogs
7 Jordan Lewis Hawthorn
So if the Bulldogs were not going to miss out on Griffen, and the Hawks were after height with Roughead the preferred choice they would select before Franklin, that means the Tigers could have also gone with Franklin at 1 and maybe still had Deledio at pick 4.
1 Lance Franklin Richmond
2 Jarryd Roughead Hawthorn
3 Ryan Griffen Western Bulldogs
4 Brett Delidio Richmond
5 Jordan Lewis Hawthorn
6 Tom Williams Western Bulldogs
7 Richard Tambling Hawthorn
Sometimes the Hawks talk about why it was Roughead before Franklin, that was to stop the Tigers getting Roughead. Below is how the Tigers hoped the draft would go for them.
1 Brett Delidio Richmond
2 Richard Tambling Hawthorn
3 Ryan Griffen Western Bulldogs
4 Jarryd Roughead Richmond
5 Lance Franklin Hawthorn
6 Tom Williams Western Bulldogs
7 Jordan Lewis Hawthorn
Hawthorn fans are probably very happy that the draft did not work out that way, although they would still have Boyle or Thorp or Dowler, or even Dawson, who could be used in Roughead's spot.
If there is a lesson here, it is that teams should draft big when they are picking up the top of the draft. Hawthorn or St Kilda will be in the 2008 AFL Grand Final. The Hawks can thank the Roughead-Franklin draft while the Saints are where they are due to the Riewoldt-Koschitzke draft. Geelong never had high picks in recent drafts, but they did acquire Ottens who went very early in his draft. Of the four remaining teams, obviously the smaller Bulldogs are an exception as they went small in so many drafts. But at least they tried here and while they did miss taking Roughead or Franklin in 2004 they did get Tom Williams.
Have a look at Jarryd Roughead’s Wikipedia site, and if you are a Roughead fan maybe send them some information as Roughead deserves more than one paragraph.
Given that he is such a tall, athletic and naturally gifted player, it was probably inevitable that Lance Franklin would become a popular player in the AFL. But it's fair to say that even his club, Hawthorn, was not expecting this — with the season (and his career) only four weeks old, he's developed such a cult following at Glenferrie that on Saturday, the club's merchandise store at the MCG ran out of the entire Franklin stock of pins and badges.
"A changing of the guard," was how one Hawk insider described it yesterday, saying youngsters such as Franklin, Sam Mitchell and Luke Hodge are gradually taking over from Shane Crawford, Nick Holland and Jonathan Hay as the most popular players at the club. But it's Lance "Buddy" Franklin — the nickname comes from his father, who is also Lance "Buddy" Franklin — who is all the rage, particularly among the younger supporters, as evidenced by the merchandise sellout and also by the way he was mobbed at a kids' footy clinic last week. And check through the Hawks' chat room websites and it seems that Franklin is the player everyone wants to talk about.
Hawthorn coach Alastair Clarkson says the weekend's 46-point win over Brisbane and a Rising Star nomination for young forward Lance Franklin have justified his decision to persist with a youth policy.
The Hawks have had six rookies make their debuts this season and recorded their first win of the season on Saturday to climb off the bottom of the AFL ladder.
1988
1 Alex McDonald - Hawthorn
2 Todd Breman - West Coast
3 Carl Dilena - Fitzroy
4 John McNamara - Kangaroos
5 Chris Naish - Richmond
6 Ray Sterrett - Geelong
7 Leon Cameron - Western Bulldogs
8 Dion Scott - Sydney
9 Michael Werner - Essendon
10 Peter Higgins - West Coast
Leon Cameron and Chris Naish are the better players out of this top 10. Naish was a very dangerous forward while Cameron was someone who could get the ball in the back half and supply it to the forwards with an accurate kick on either foot.
Geelong needed to look closer to home when they picked. Instead of taking Sterrett who was from the other side of Australia, he was recruited from East Fremantle, the Cats could have driven an hour or two down the road where Leon Cameron was playing for South Warrnambool.
The big news at the time was Hawthorn and their trade to acquire the top overall pick. They were probably hoping that Alex McDonald would be a big part of keeping Hawthorn up the top of the ladder throughout the 1990s but that didn't work.
North Melbourne was the worst team picking in the top 10, as they were the only team here that received zero games from their top 10 pick, but when they picked again in the 1988 draft they selected Anthony Stevens. 1988 was also the draft that Chris Grant went at pick 105, it is safe to say that all of the clubs above, except for the Bulldogs, wish they had taken him when they had the chance.
Ranking The AFL Draft Top 10s
1988
1998
1986
1996
1991
1995
1990
1987
Clarkson said the club's younger players, such as Lance Franklin, Jarryd Roughead and Josh Thurgood, had established a foundation for future success.
"These kids are going to be great players for us, but they just need some time and need some experience like young Roughead did against (Cameron) Mooney on the weekend," he said.
Hawthorn's Jarryd Roughead is the round 19 nominee for the AFL rising star award after his solid all-round performance against Brisbane at the Gabba on Sunday.
He is the third Hawthorn player to be nominated this season joining Lance Franklin and Jordan Lewis.
The future of football is said to be Jarryd Roughead.
1998
1 Des Headland - Brisbane
2 Justin Longmuir - Fremantle
3 Nic Fosdike - Sydney
4 Ryan Fitzgerald - Sydney
5 Michael Stevens - Port Adelaide
6 Murray Vance - Carlton
7 Josh Carr - Port Adelaide
8 Jude Bolton - Sydney
9 Mark McVeigh - Essendon
10 Brandon Hill - West Coast
Probably not the smartest draft class of all time. The Swans managed to find some players, as they picked up two future premiership onballers, but they also missed with another early pick.
The story for this draft was Brisbane deciding between Headland and Longmuir. Headland never fulfilled his potential with the Lions, and would leave to join Longmuir at the Dockers. Longmuir had more talent than anyone else in the top 10, but injuries cut short his career. Josh Carr would win a premiership before departing for Fremantle too, but unlike Headland it seems he had a return ticket and could be a Power player again soon.
Carlton have shown they can select star players, when given the number 1 pick, but they miss with a lot of other top 10 picks. They gave Vance a chance, which was not a good idea.
It seems like M McVeigh was drafted more recently, he has made a steady progression during his career at Essendon and is now one of their main stars.
Ranking The AFL Draft Top 10s
1998
1986
1996
1991
1995
1990
1987